Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Transparency (Score 1) 220

I'm very much not an expert with this stuff, but it seems to me that if a particular strut is going to fail at 10,001lbs and you test it to 10,000lbs, it might pass the test but you still don't want to reuse it. There has to be some cutoff point where you're causing long term damage, but it's still functioning to requirements, right?

Comment Re:Can someone answer me this? (Score 1, Insightful) 164

If you have to manually block people, then you're going to get a lot of fly-by abuse from new accounts that people make to dodge the block lists.

If the system allows users to say "auto-hide all people from my screen who have a 50% troll rating or higher", you're going to get a lot of people abusing the system. It's REALLY, REALLY common on political discussion sites for users to dogpile on people whose opinions they don't like and flag them as trolls, and often they use bots to do it more efficiently.

Comment Re:Obligatory XKCD (Score 1) 581

Public service announcement: "free speech" is a concept that exists outside the context of the US constitution. Here's some more thoughts on that, from reddit of all places (http://www.reddit.com/r/TiADiscussion/comments/2h53ov/the_irony_in_xkcds_free_speech_comic/):

You've all probably seen it before, but in case you haven't, here it is: http://xkcd.com/1357/
It's about free speech, and how some idiots think free speech means you can say whatever you want without any repercussions. Of course that's not true, as Randall points out, the first amendment just means that the government can't persecute you for simply having an opinion, people however are free to react to you however they want.
However I've noticed this comic being posted by people solely as justification for censorship or as a simple reply to a complaint about censorship. Instead of making an actual argument for censorship specific to the situation at hand they post this... but what does the comic say then? That the most compelling thing you can say for censoring is that it's not illegal to censor? Ironically this is a mirror image of what the title text of the comic says about defending your argument with free speech, only you're defending your censorship with the lack of free speech.
Picture this:
Person A censors Person B
B: "Freedom of speech! It's literally not illegal to say something so I should be able to say what I want without repercussions."
A: "XKCD comic! It's literally not illegal to censor you so I'm going to censor you."
And no one gives any legitimate arguments for justifying their actions or opinions.

Comment Re:Who cares? (Score 1) 581

reddit became as popular as it is in large part because it allowed everyone to talk about anything they wanted. And it confuses you why people might be angry that they are now not only changing that, but also taking their users for idiots by lying about what's really going on? Let me put it this way -- if you found out your girlfriend of 10 years has started fucking your rich neighbor, wouldn't you be a tad ticked off? Or would you be perfectly satisfied by someone telling you you can go find another girlfriend?

Comment Re:This legislation brought to you by.. (Score 1) 446

Example of higher-level government bodies overriding lower-level ones... This came up in Washington a while back, and could come up again. Gun possession, or pot possession, whichever you're more fond of. If it's legal in your state, but a small town makes it illegal, then what happens if you have $item in your car and you stop through that town to fuel up? Suddenly you've just broken an unreasonable law for no good reason.

Similarly, if that small town makes it illegal to sell GMOs that aren't labeled with a very specific frowny-face logo...you're going to have a lot of inadvertent lawbreakers. Especially if they say something dumb like "you need to label whether it was grown in a field that has ever grown GMOs", something that might never cross your mind. You can be sure there's a lot of creative lawmakers out there, and you never know what magical categories your product will wind up in!

Slashdot Top Deals

"Ninety percent of baseball is half mental." -- Yogi Berra

Working...