Comment Access vs. Requirement (Score 1) 453
There has been some discussion about similar issues here in China; the college entrance exam has recently reduced the total score for English on the test and increased the weight of Chinese. Disregarding the name-calling, I think there is some similarity in the topics.
I support the changes in China simply because I think that most people are wasting their time learning English here. For the small part of the population who ends up using it, it could be very valuable. But for the vast majority, it is a waste of time.
I think the talk about programming is similar, I think what we should offer is access, but that certainly doesn't mean everyone should learn it. In fact, for a vast majority, learning programming will be frustrating and offer very little value to their life. However for those who do use it, learning from a young age and having resources to explore that will be invaluable.
There is a whole other discussion here about what should be the baseline for a well-rounded education. Does some understanding of algorithms play a part of that? I think it should. But do we need to teach everyone programming? Probably not.
I support the changes in China simply because I think that most people are wasting their time learning English here. For the small part of the population who ends up using it, it could be very valuable. But for the vast majority, it is a waste of time.
I think the talk about programming is similar, I think what we should offer is access, but that certainly doesn't mean everyone should learn it. In fact, for a vast majority, learning programming will be frustrating and offer very little value to their life. However for those who do use it, learning from a young age and having resources to explore that will be invaluable.
There is a whole other discussion here about what should be the baseline for a well-rounded education. Does some understanding of algorithms play a part of that? I think it should. But do we need to teach everyone programming? Probably not.