Comment Re:Put your money into speakers (Score 1) 433
Yes! A complete signal chain with quality equipment is the best way to get your $whatever sound.
I've been writing and recording songs for most of my life, and have been all-digital for many years. By the time I kind of knew what I was doing, I took a step back and re-learned how to listen to music, with the question in my mind, "What the heck is wrong with how *my* stuff sounds vs. classic recordings?" The answer I arrived at was: The absence of analog saturation. All of the old-school analog hardware that all of the old beloved classics are recorded through *add distortion* in the form of the harmonics created by analog saturation. This distortion makes sounds more pleasing to human ears. I had lingered for years under the impression that leveraging the "exactness of digital" was a desirable achievement; but the "color of analog" is the secret audio sauce.
So, does vinyl "sound better" than digital? The "science of vinyl" shows that it absolutely cannot match the dynamics of a digital recording. Digital is capable of better stereo imaging; a 26db better dynamic range; and can reproduce a higher frequency bandwidth. Unfortunately, the superior specs of digital recording have been abused since the inception of CDs because of the so-called "loudness wars." Some early digital mastering engineer must have thought, "Thank goodness I don't have to worry about the needle jumping," and subsequently turned everything up to 11, forgetting what "dynamics" is all about. And so, dynamics did, in a sense, vanish from popular digital recordings. If you've only been exposed to digital re-masters that are louder and less dynamic than the original recordings, or contemporary music recorded digitally to be "loud" and "sound good on earbuds," I can see how the limitations of vinyl would represent a "more dynamic" sound to you.
The resurgence of vinyl seems-- at best-- a cute and hip marketing ploy to collect something, and "Sound Quality!" is the mantra of the suckers who own lots of vinyl. It's about the analog saturation and dynamics of the recording. And digital can reproduce that better than vinyl. I'd much rather collect music in a medium that sounds best, requires no physical maintenance, and will retain the quality of the recorded material forever, without degradation.
Maybe, one day, the loudness wars of the Music Industry will end, and great-sounding (and appropriately saturated) digital music will become the norm and sound awesome through an excellent set of speakers. Or earbuds. Or your little monophonic cell phone speaker.