Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:I do not think that means what you think it mea (Score 1) 154

General principles are great, and I'm in favor of them. However, that is not the same thing as the obligations spelled out in a treaty. It's like saying that the speed limit in Maryland has something to do with driving in England.

And it should be noted both that the Continental army was in fact uniformed, and fought well before the Geneva conventions were written.

Comment I do not think that means what you think it means (Score 4, Insightful) 154

The Geneva conventions apply to uniformed soldiers fighting in declared wars between states. They specifically exclude "irregular" combatants who dress as civilians or are not acting on behalf of a state.

An argument can be made in favor of extending the protections of the Geneva conventions to cover "irregular" forces, but an argument could be made against it as well.

Comment tinfoil hat ++ (Score 2, Interesting) 281

Just because you can't ping something doesn't mean it isn't in use. ARIN and the other RIRs require extensive documentation before they give out more space, and all of the companies you've mentioned have received it. I recommend reading up on how a SWIP works, followed by getting an understanding of rWhois. At that point you might have a better understanding of some of the issues. Heck, NANOG has had some excellent discussions on the subject of IPv4 address reclamation, and the outcome of those discussions is that it's a lot of work for very, very little benefit.

Comment Re:Are we serious this time? (Score 0, Flamebait) 281

As someone who regularly configures and manages large networks in IPv4 and IPv6, I'd love to hear exactly which improvements you mean. Perhaps you mean the need to have both DHCPv6 AND RA for SLAAC running all the time on a LAN (or you have to cheat off of IPv4 for DNS server addresses); perhaps you mean the lack of RA filtering capability, which makes m-i-t-m attacks a heck of a lot easier; perhaps you're not familiar with v4 multicast.

As for the fragmentation of IPv4 address space, yes, that's a concern if you are running routers which operate in the DFZ. If you aren't, then it's not such a big issue. In any case, routing table growth is likely to be substantially worse in the v6 space than in the v4 space, unless the regional registries can work out policies to keep the number of routes announced to the DFZ to be on the same order of magnitude as the number of ASNs assigned.

In short, there's lots wrong with v6 - the ONLY absolute plus for it is the larger address space. All the rest is consultant-foo.

Comment Re:No shit, sherlock. (Score 1) 485

CDs and DVDs are not exempt from sales tax, exempting their online counterparts is wildly inconsistent.

CDs and DVDs are things, each of which has individual countability, and which has an integral nature (i.e. half a CD is worthless). By comparison, download is a verb, and what is downloaded is a collection of organized ones and zeroes. Half of a song file can play half of a song.

Why should this particular set of ones and zeroes be taxed, while other sets are not?

Consider a radio broadcaster on the PA border with NY. Would their broadcasts be subject to tax? What about Pandora? Or CNN?

There aren't a whole lot of bright lines, other than perhaps "no taxes on online purchases" or "tax per bit, collected by the ISP" - if you try to tax things which are somewhere between those, the tax-dodge strategies will get more and more clever.

Comment Re:That should have read... (Score 1) 260

I'd characterize Teller's role in the H-bomb as similar to Oppenheimer's role for the A-bomb. As Oppenheimer is routinely called the "father" of the A-bomb, it seems reasonable to use the same language. Obviously, both projects were the result of a substantial number of people working a lot of hours.

Slashdot Top Deals

"More software projects have gone awry for lack of calendar time than for all other causes combined." -- Fred Brooks, Jr., _The Mythical Man Month_

Working...