Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Cognitive dissonance (Score 1) 224

Software is not scarce, developer time is. I'll never understand the cognitive dissonance that makes people think a non-scarce resource should be treated like a scarce one.

It's not cognitive dissonance; you explain it right there -- a scarce resource is required to create a valuable but non-scarce resource.

By establishing a social contract where everyone gives you control (for a limited time) over the distribution of a non-scarce resource you created, the creation of more non-scarce but valuable resources will be encouraged.

The flaw in copyright is not that principle but rather the imbalance of its present implementation.

The entire purpose of copyright has been lost, and in its place given birth to the erroneous belief in an inherent moral that people should own non-scarce resources once they release them.

Comment Re:Insightful? (Score 1) 268

No one is forcing you to accept a job you don't want.

Exactly -- that is a key difference between a job and being a slave. And for whatever reason, the GGP chose not to accept the hooker job.

The only thing that degrades hookers is people's attitudes towards them

A hooker may also degrade themselves. Keep in mind that people grade all jobs, and sex is a special act -- it is necessary for procreation (families, in general) and it is often, and perhaps biologically wired to be, an emotional act. People naturally have strong feelings about it and when it is appropriate in a way that is unlike almost all other jobs.

and the exploitation that we allow to happen because we push prostitution underground.

Good point. Legalizing (and regulating?) prostitution may be a better option. I view this as a separate argument than social stigma.

Comment Re:What is the atmosphere inside China? (Score 1) 249

Superpowers are the best at spreading their cultures and ideologies, but I'd argue that all powers do it, particularly when they expand. The salient difference is how they do it -- whether through violence or through trade or other free choice. The reality is always a mixture of those, but the make-up of that mixture is important yet difficult to weigh.

Conflating non-violent missionaries with violent conquerors confuses the morality at issue.

Comment Re:Doesn't matter what country you are in... (Score 1) 667

You make an excellent point that the GP ignores.

But one benefit of regulation is that it gives the government authority to arbitrarily choose to examine internal processes before an injury even occurs. Should private citizens have similar authority? If not, it seems that they would be at a disadvantage to provide a similar preventative service.

There's also a significant cost to litigation that individuals tend to avoid, though that might be ameliorated with proper incentives to expose fraud.

Comment Re:Not really useful (Score 3, Informative) 256

In a box approximately 1nm on a side there is a north pole with no matching south pole. So there are magnetic field lines flowing out of the box with no matching field lines flowing in. Of course "over there" there is a south pole which has field lines flowing in without field lines flowing out.

Except, from my reading above, it seems that the matching "monopoles" are connected by a long series of aligned dipoles resembling solenoidal tubes, so there is mag field in the dipoles flowing into the box. Sure the "in" field occupies a very small area, but in/out still balances. Is this incorrect? If not, I don't see how this is evidence of the existence of monopoles.

And, as an aside, given the parallel you draw with conservation of charge, is there any corresponding persistent and unique connection between (e.g.) an electron and positron pair after they are created?

Comment Re:Great (Score 1) 412

As with the "no true scotsman" argument, you both have to agree upon on a single definition for capitalism.

Keep in mind that capitalism is not anarchy. e.g. it certainly requires that fraud be prosecuted. At some point, intentional confusion and misinformation become fraud. Likewise, capitalism is aided by an informed market.

Comment Re:Article is a troll (Score 1) 1365

While I don't like the physically centralized registry of Windows, having a standard format and api for easy, live, dynamic modification and notification of configuration is a great boon.

Text files which each have a different format, which must be parsed and altered in their entirety to maintain consistency, and which often are not live, are not as useful or advanced.

Comment Re:Abso-freakin'-lutely! (Score 1) 276

If it's not too much trouble, could you please elaborate on a couple of points?:

(1) Examples of the "trade giveaways" where the U.S. gave up its natural trade advantages.

(2) The key differences between global trade and global economy. You seem to suggest that economy leads to homogeneity while trade does not.

Comment Re:Linux - How "Free" is it? (Score 1) 508

After reading a book about Linux, tuning a system for someone, and walking her through it, why did I have to post on a technology discussion website to find out about it?

Because the freedom of Linux also results in an abundance of fragmentation. Diverse Window Managers aren't even close to the worst of it.

What is remarkable is how the freedom to share and customize can actually result in less sharing of code. Too many options breeds confusion which can be a significant impediment to actually getting things done which is the purpose of freedom.

It's also fascinating to consider the parallel pitfalls of freedom in economics. It can be chaotic, confusing, lacking controls, and often more difficult, but the system as a whole evolves better.

Similarly, Linux evolves and I am confident that it will eventually solidify on excellent general purpose solutions. I just don't know when that will happen.

Slashdot Top Deals

Beware of Programmers who carry screwdrivers. -- Leonard Brandwein

Working...