Submission + - Global Warming or Recedin Crust? Tiny Island Gone.
iliketrash writes: These articles announce the disappearance of tiny New Moore Island (aka South Talpatti) under the waters of the Bay of Bengal. An expert blames it on rising sea level due to global warming. Could be. But consider that the island is said to have once reached 2 meters above sea level. Sea levels are said (by the same expert) to have risen 5 mm/year since 2000 and 3 mm/year before that. That means that the island's elevation was mapped 650 years ago, in 1360, a tenuous claim at best. Also consider that volcanic activity and plate tectonics are constantly make new and higher mountains. Unless matter is being created out of nothing, the material making up new mountains has to come from somewhere, which means that the earth's crust has to be falling someplace, possibly many places.
This story appears to be appearing in various media as solid evidence of global warming. But isn't is possible that the Bay of Bengal is sinking? Or that the sea level is rising at the same time? It seems to me that uncritical analysis of data which "obviously" supports a foregone conclusion is the hallmark of groupthink.
[Editor: I can't figure out how to set links to the two articles referenced by "These articles." The links are: ]
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/8584665.stm
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/24/new-moore-island-disappea_n_511162.html
This story appears to be appearing in various media as solid evidence of global warming. But isn't is possible that the Bay of Bengal is sinking? Or that the sea level is rising at the same time? It seems to me that uncritical analysis of data which "obviously" supports a foregone conclusion is the hallmark of groupthink.
[Editor: I can't figure out how to set links to the two articles referenced by "These articles." The links are: ]
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/8584665.stm
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/24/new-moore-island-disappea_n_511162.html