Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:That's the problem (Score 1) 564

I trust the file name implicitly... as the name of the file. Like Shakespeare said: "What's in a name? That which we call a rose, by any other name would smell...". Rose.jpg is an entirely trustworthy name for a batch file; and it should be designated as a batch file by a file type field, not by hacking the filename.

Comment Re:Hiding it and always was a bad idea (Score 1) 564

I disagree. We don't need extensions. We need an entirely separate file-type field. We don't store the creation date in the name, or the security bits in the name, or the archive bit in the name, so why store the file type in the name? Extensions are a hack that should have been dealt with decades ago.

Comment Re:Good operating systems don't use extensions (Score 1) 564

I agree. The file type should not be a function of the filename, but its own field, like the date. Hiding the extension gives the illusion of a separate file type field, but it's a hack. It's a hack masking another hack, and like most other such cruft, we owe its continued existence to Microsoft.

Comment Re:Better idea (Score 1) 564

Instead of insisting that modern OS design carry forward an old and archaic standard set of digits describing the type of file, show users visual information about the file type/associations in way that is meaningful to them.

That's an issue of he UI, not how the attribute is atached to the file. Processors still prefer 'digits' to dancing icons. Its up to the O/S to map one to the other consistently and in a manner the user will still understand.

Impossible. The "extension" isn't a separate field. The file name field was repurposed into a combined file name/file type field. As long as users have access to the whole field, there will be problems.

Extensions should be eliminated, and a separate file type field, uneditable by the user except by special program (like the date fields, ownership/permission flags, and backup status indicator) should be created.

Comment Re:Interesting idea, nasty downsides (Score 1) 93

I switched my laptop from a HDD to a SSD. Before the changeover, it used to be that once the login screen came up, I could log in. Now it boots much faster, but now when the login screen comes up, I have to wait for 30 seconds or so until the keyboard becomes responsive. (And before you suggest it, I have updated the bios to the latest version with no effect.)

Slashdot Top Deals

2.4 statute miles of surgical tubing at Yale U. = 1 I.V.League

Working...