Comment Re:This tired old saw again. (Score 2) 755
It might be god from our perspective, but it might be a let down of a god in other ways. Consider this scenario.
300 years in the future we discover some way to simulate an entire universe easily within a computer. So we create one and let it run for billions of years inside the simulation till intelligent sentient life emerges. This life makes great strides, it goes to space, it advances, until one day we look in and decide to "pull one of the beings out." We pull the "mind of the being" out of the simulation and put it in a robotic body. Maybe at first its amazed at everything, we show it the world it lived in and the things we can do to the simulation; and for a short while it calls us god. But eventually the being realizes there are still things about this "outside" world we don't understand, and suddenly it comes to the realization that if I'm from a simulation what if they are too? Are they really god? Is the being on the outside of this outside god? It could be simulations inside simulations to infinity so long as the simulation (B) inside a simulation (A) can be done within the limits of sim A. We know nothing of the physical limitations of the simulation outside the one we are in.
The point is that we can never be sure the being we are talking to is actually "god" in the sense that we tend to think about it in religion and language.
300 years in the future we discover some way to simulate an entire universe easily within a computer. So we create one and let it run for billions of years inside the simulation till intelligent sentient life emerges. This life makes great strides, it goes to space, it advances, until one day we look in and decide to "pull one of the beings out." We pull the "mind of the being" out of the simulation and put it in a robotic body. Maybe at first its amazed at everything, we show it the world it lived in and the things we can do to the simulation; and for a short while it calls us god. But eventually the being realizes there are still things about this "outside" world we don't understand, and suddenly it comes to the realization that if I'm from a simulation what if they are too? Are they really god? Is the being on the outside of this outside god? It could be simulations inside simulations to infinity so long as the simulation (B) inside a simulation (A) can be done within the limits of sim A. We know nothing of the physical limitations of the simulation outside the one we are in.
The point is that we can never be sure the being we are talking to is actually "god" in the sense that we tend to think about it in religion and language.