Comment Re:Hogwash (Score 1) 183
Quite the contrary: Our current musical scale is a human creation and has something to do with how sound works.
Obviously, there are a lot of different ways to make scales and tonalities and music (and even music that doesn't have scales or tonalities). But there is no question that the currently used western scales and tonalities are a complex interplay among the physical properties of sound, the human auditory system, and human thought about sound.
Obviously another culture could take on this same elements, the same interplay and come up with a complete different answer, because the physical properties of sound remain the same but the other two elements are quite subjective. But that is a lot different than saying our current musical scale "has nothing to do with how sound works." Pretty much every single element of the scale and how it is used is shaped by some portion of the physical property of sound.