The Secret Squirrels should not be monitoring all Americans. They should be tracking terrorists!
Great idea! Wonder why noone ever thought of that before.
So, any ideas about how to go about "tracking terrorists"? I'm assuming you're going to start by identifying some of them? And then you're going to do what, exactly?
No, there's not a whole lot of really good reason for warrantless (or even warranted) wiretapping of everyone. Nonetheless, security takes a bit more than "well, we should track terrorists!!!"
Note that the real question is more properly phrased as "how much liberty should we sacrifice in exchange for how much security?"
Everyone will have a different answer to that (mostly divided along "how much of YOUR liberty for MY security" lines. A small number of people will rephrase that as "how much of MY liberty for YOUR security", and an even smaller number will say "I'd rather have the liberty than the security, thank you".
Most of the latter group will, of course, change their minds the first time they lose a job for an extended period, but that's neither here nor there.
What is relevant is that the question won't go away. You can't have absolute liberty and absolute security at the same time. So finding a level acceptable to as many people as possible is essential.
And mostly done by guess and by golly....