Know some one really smart person that you respect that used an AOL email address? Just that one experience negates my dislike for AOL, hence, I lose my propensity to jump to a simplistic conclusion. Moreover, some of the same people have found it effective for their needs. Finally, who am I to judge.
A supposedly lame email address may not seem as dumb at some time in the future, if perhaps the company that has a theme of doing no evil decides it was mistaken. Say we discover a <i>cloud</i> over our heads, it knows many of our damaging secrets and we are blackmailed into doing its bidding. Our formally generous hosts have other goals and are no longer the cool location for our correspondence. It need not be the company alluded to that follows this path, any cloud would do. However, in contrast just a Lame E-Mail Address would be much deferrable if only we had one to protect ourselves from our superficiality and self deluding knowledge.
It is so much easier to judge others on simple external signs and ignore the harder task of judging the value of the person.