Comment Cause an Elected Dictatorship ? (Score 1) 465
Look, I'm as revolted by some of the campaign finance scandals as anyone. But I'm also very cautious of well-meaning reform attempts that likely will have totally different effects once they work their way through. Laws always do -- wrongdoers adapt in generally undesireable ways. Worse, I fear the scandals and reform is just a deliberate smoke-screen for a power grab.
To my knowledge, the US and Japan are the only G-8 countries with independent legislators. Everywhere else, the parties control lists/seats because they control the money. The UK/ca/AU/nz Prime Ministers are effectively elected dictators -- remember how Tony Blair (UK-L) put down three successive (perfectly reasonable) backbencher revolts over Iraq? That does not in any sense resemble democracy.
I'm afraid if US Reps/Sens do not control their own funds & re-elections, the money/power vacuum will be filled by someone else, most likely the D&R Party Central Committees. Which will give them (the Prez) power, and remove the legislature as a check on the executive.