First off, even getting that laptop was fruit of the poisoned tree because they got it using evidence the NSA gathered through illegal wiretapping programs.
Citation?
Even then, Ulbreit admitted he built the site. He just didn't run it during the period in question. The entire point of the name "Dread Pirate Roberts" is that anyone can use it.
So he admitted buying the gun and evidence puts him at the murder scene... but you are still going to fight the idea that he pulled the trigger? You can be an accessory to a crime without directly taking part.
But then lets just ignore the other evidence on his laptop which did show him being a more active runner of the site than you suggest.
Besides, the site did use Tor correctly.
Really? So you've personally audited it and certified that in your capacity as an AC Tor expert?
FYI: Posting to Stackoverflow with your own name when trying to learn how to setup a Tor hidden service isn't the brightest thing when you are trying to not have the site tied to you.
It didn't help because the NSA has infiltrated Tor, which should surprise no one, because it was originally built by the US DOD anyway.
Like many, I'm still waiting to see/hear of these secret backdoors in Tor that were somehow inserted not through rouge check-ins... but through large checks to the Tor foundation.
Lemme guess... 9/11 was an inside job?