Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Sure, let's have more unschooling... (Score 1) 1345

I'm not sure why you assume anything about my father being strict. Perhaps you just read a book about conservative/liberal politics, and are keen to apply your new buzzwords?

Anyway, I beg you to show me one kid who would by his/her own accord sit down and learn to read, write, do math, and so on. Most kids would rather play games and colour books all day, which is what "unschooling" is all about.

Actually applying some cognitive science terminology to your rant about stupid lazy people. People need to pull themselves up by their bootstraps, right?

No one ever said that the kids would be learning on their own, but that they would be learning about what interests them. My daughter was three and couldn't wait to learn to read. Kids love, absolutely love to learn, as long as we don't impose a system on them that smashes that love. Playing games and coloring are a very important part of growing up. They will do that, until they have done that as much as they want, then they will go do something else, naturally. Let Education Always Remain Natural (LEARN).

Comment Re:If the parents (Score 1) 1345

Unschoolers that I know, and since I am one, I know a lot of them, are every one of them is very conscience of socializing.

I was a lot more open to the idea of "unschooling" before I read this tortured sentence. Really, if they sent words to Guantanamo to be questioned, you'd be the person standing in the water-boarding room waiting for them.

Good point. Actually, I'm a product of public school. My unschooled daughter would tear me up for having written such a poor sentence. Doh!

Comment Re:Great idea! (Score 1) 1345

Unschoolers don't use a cirriculum. The idea of unschooling is that when you come up with something that sounds interesting enough to learn, you figure out how to learn about that subject. Go as deep or as shallow as your interest takes you. Just like in the adult world. When we started homeschooling our kids, we were using a curriculum, and the kids did it, but they were bored silly pretty quickly. We came to call this "school at home". What's the point of that? Once we embraced unschooling, our kids blossomed. The loved it. They learned so much on their own it was astonishing.

The public school methodology works great for what it was designed for. The problem is that it was designed to create good factory workers for the dawn of the industrial age. For today's world, the school system is broken, and unschoolers aren't going to wait for someone to fix it. Taking action. Taking control.

The unschooling community is very much like the open source community. It's about freedom and control of your own destiny.

Comment Re:Good luck in university (Score 1) 1345

No, they don't. With the possible exception of sham universities (unaccredited christian universities that are deathly afraid of proper education), no university seeks out homeschooled kids.

And you know this how?

There used to be aversion by universities to homeschooled children. More recently they have learned that kids who learn at home or on their own are better prepared for the independence of college than most of their public schooled peers. Yes, real, state run universities accept willingly applications from homeschool children. They can't "seek" them out because they are not aware of them, but if a homeschool kid applies, then they are recruited every bit as much as a public school "A" student.

Comment Re:Great idea! (Score 1) 1345

But, to succeed (at either college admissions or finding a desirable non-college job), a student has to have a balance of useful skills. If the parent lacks those skills, lacks the tools, or lacks the commitment to teach and promote those skills within their child, this could turn out really badly for the child.

If the parent lacks the skills, they find someone else to teach the kid that skill, if that's what the kid really wants to learn. Unschooling is about being and learning in the real world, not some artificial teaching environment.

Comment Re:If the parents (Score 2, Insightful) 1345

Most homeschoolers I know are people who aren't sociable and just don't want to deal with the daily social 'grind' of dealing with people. Also they ahve some fear the child will be exposed to something outside there own beliefs. Political or theological.

Those aren't unschoolers. Unschoolers that I know, and since I am one, I know a lot of them, are every one of them is very conscience of socializing. They just want control of their children's education, and not turn it over to the state and the kids peers. I would argue that the main problem with public school is that we group all the kids by age rather than skill in each subject. By grouping by age, we end up with lots of peer groups that divide our children in ways that don't exist in the "adult" world.

Slashdot Top Deals

"And remember: Evil will always prevail, because Good is dumb." -- Spaceballs

Working...