Comment Re:Ridiculous. (Score 1) 914
Yes, precisely. The generally regarded theoretical justification for criminalization is:
1. Segregation of harmful individuals from the balance of society (aka specific deterrence); and
2. A warning to others to not commit crimes (aka general deterrence).
In other words, the point of the criminal system is on the prevention of future crimes. The only purpose of these drugs consistent with our theory of the criminal system would be if there were some repair happening in the brains of those taking the drugs, but it is apparent from the article that thought has not entered into the minds of the authors.
What is now broadly accepted by most criminal lawyers, judges and those who study criminal theory is that general deterrence is not related to the punishment at all but rather to the likelihood of being caught. In other words, having more police causes less crime. The simple reason being that consequence rarely enters into the mind of those about to commit crimes - unless there are constant reminders (i.e. police presence).