Comment It has one flaw.... (Score 1) 401
... the UI. Which is partially stored server side and manipulated only serverside, which causes major lag for ANYTHING using the UI.
The combat I enjoy (it's far slower paced than say wow or eq2 though), the crafting is ok, the class system I really like, etc... but the UI is just hideous, it's designed for a controller and using one alleviates 50% of the issues... but not the lag. Until they can fix the lag (and the only fix is moving the ui clientside completely... which I doubt they're willing to do.) there are going to be no good reviews, the ui is so bad it overshadows EVERYTHING.
The slower combat and old school style are definitely not for everyone, but the UI pushes it towards "not for anyone."