Would you rather go to a pay model?
Tell you what.
First, we'll kill all of the people who run analytics companies, and destroy all of their data.
Then we'll pass sane consumer protection laws which limit what they can collect about you, and what they can do with it.
Then we might start to talk about how to pay for the internet.
Right now on Slashdot as I type this, Google, Ooyala, Rpxnow, Scorecard research, Janrain, Double Click, Comscore ... all of these entities would be tracking me if I wasn't blocking them.
I'm not willing to accept their bullshit "by visiting this site you give us unlimited rights to track, monitor, collate, sell, and otherwise abuse your data". I have no relationship with those companies, and I get no compensation for being their "product". Which means I will block the hell out of anything which is going to help Slashdot profit from douchebags.
I have no business relationship with these analytics and advertising companies.
Take these assholes out of the equation, or don't even talk to me about how to fund the internet. I'm not funding someone's website with my personal information.
Fuck that.
The notion that some greedy corporation should feel entitled to my data is the problem. Finding ways to accommodate them is not the solution.