Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Locked Down (Score 4, Insightful) 331

This.

It's a false dichotomy to discuss "streamlined user experience" versus "user freedom" as if one is completely at odds with the other. To provide a streamlined experience simply requires good design and sensible defaults. You don't have to lock-out the user from changing those defaults, accessing the full capabilities of the device, or repurposing the device entirely.

Of course it makes sense that vendors of locked-down solutions would spread this misunderstanding. They want to enforce consumer lock-in to their product/services stack. By convincing customers that the lock-in is actually to their benefit, they now have people effectively begging to give up their user freedoms. What bothers me is that media outlets seem not to have generally caught on to this lie. Instead they repeat the false dichotomy, as if it were a fact of nature. I guess it is because computers are still fairly misunderstood by the public at large. (By comparison, most people would not buy it if they hired an electrician who installed locks on their fusebox, telling them that they'll have to call/pay him when the fuses blow... because only then can he guarantee a proper "electrical user experience"...)

Comment Re:Need some Libertarian clarification (Score 1) 799

... Without that juicy legislation by Congress, they would have been damn sure their stuff was safe, because they would be on the hook for the entire damages otherwise...

Right. BP's corporate misfeasance is Congresses fault, because we know corporation always act in an optimal way to preserve their long-term self-interest and would never cut corners otherwise to risk horribly expensive disasters.

Let's look at something that BP was responsible for less than four years ago: the Alaska oil pipeline shutdown (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14219844/).

Set aside the environmental aspects of the spill entirely and just focus on how BP managed that pipeline which delivered 8% of U.S. oil consumption and $30 million of revenue a day. Obviously in possession of such a cash cow, BP's enlightened self-interest ensured that they would keep that pipeline in good condition so that that billion-dollar-a-month gusher would never dry up. But did they? Nooo... they cut corners on maintenance and suffered an entirely avoidable shutdown.

The Libertarian notion, taken up by many non-Libertarian right wingers also -- that regulation is unnecessary since the discipline of the marketplace guarantees good corporate behavior and citizenship (And maximizes economic performance in the short and long terms! Really, no downside at all it seems!) -- is a quaint bit of Nineteenth Century economic utopianism.

Although pointing in a different direction, this "perfect free market" notion is strikingly similar to the character of Marxist thought - another bit of economic fantasy literature harkening back to the 1800s. Both are elegant theoretical structures, so pleasing to its adherents, that the naked evidence of its disastrous failures (and thus the falsity of their premises) in the real world go entirely unacknowledged.

Comment Re:Come on guys... (Score 1) 495

I would rather have to code in Objective-C than wait for and have to buy a new version of Adobe Flash, just to get the capabilities made available by Apple's Xcode.
Which is why you can code on Obj-C and not depend on Flash. Now, what about the people who don't care about using the latest (but world-changing, no doubt) feature and who don't want to learn Obj-C?

Nobody ever died from having too much choices (I think).

Comment Re:Silly Brits (Score 1) 568

If several of the larger states in America had proportional voting with the electoral college, America would also have to be worrying about coalition governments or in that case a coalition president taking over the White House.

How so? As you allude to later in your post, anything short of an Electoral College majority throws the election of President to the House (with the vote to be taken by states), and the election of Vice-President to the Senate. But, once elected, the President isn't subject to Congress (impeachment excepted) any more than the Congress is subject to the President. So, I am unclear as to what your "coalition" idea would mean.

Comment Re:Perspective from a Juror on this Case (Score 1) 982

One more question I hope you can clarify. I believe there is a lot of misinformation about this case in the media. But the most critical issue goes like this (quoted from sfgate):

Newsom testified that the city had been "in peril" because officials were blocked from access to police records, payroll data and other information.

The idea is he has brought down the city network and cut off certain department from access. But a conflicting account from more technical source is that the city network is fully functional, only that IT is unable to administer the network. Which one is a more true picture?

This probably won't change the verdict. But the public (and the mayor) should get a clearer picture on the actual extent of the problem before making their judgement.

Comment Re:Apple also owns h264 patents (Score 1) 944

which, btw, until 2016, is essentially FREE except for large media companies that already pay for that for general video encoding (not hosting, think TV studios), and for companies with over 25,000 paying subscribers.

Applegets no kickbacks from people using H.264 other than they don't have to cross-code support for other formats into quicktime (which they chose not to do for 15 years, so why would that change anyway).

Comment Re:won't take long... (Score 1) 225

for these kids to realize that the "glamorous" lifestyle of the video game designer is a lie. More like death marches galore, low pay, and shady companies.

Research this stuff first kids!

Very true, but let's not forget another detail: many folks seem to think building video games == playing video games. I'd be willing to bet that while initial interest may be high, the drop-out rate will be through the roof. With a flurry of video game buffs enrolling in these classes (many of which are likely to be non-programmers), there is bound to be a lot of students caught like a deer in headlights when they learn that game development is one of the most difficult forms of programming in existence.

Of course, those who are artistically inclined might actually have an easier shot at making it through: as they could get into the art-design aspects of game development. I'd further suspect that most of the graduates will fall in this category -- and hence, will get the chance to experience the game development industry in it's full glory.

Comment Re:File a complaint, don't just talk (Score 1) 546

Oh please. This is a ridiculous lawsuit that should immediately get thrown out of court.

I might as well try and sue Dell because I can no longer run OS/2 on their systems.

Did Dell remove the ability to run OS/2 from existing systems, and force that change on you, blocking your ability to access the internet untill you accept the loss?

Slashdot Top Deals

So you think that money is the root of all evil. Have you ever asked what is the root of money? -- Ayn Rand

Working...