Comment Re:nightmares (Score 1) 495
If you research into 100 different ideas, and take them all the way from "Conception" to "Reduction to Practice" then you have a decent chance of winning a patent fight on them.
However, if you conceive of 100 different ideas, put them in your desk drawer, and then only pay attention to them (and reduce them to practice) when someone else has done something cool, you'll struggle to prove "Diligence" and hence won't be able to knock the other guy out.
The US patent system most certainly has flaws, but it does rewards inventor for inventing stuff, as opposed to people who can fill forms out. Alternatively, you can reward people who share (by filing a patent).
Neither first-to-file or first-to-invent are perfect (and the tradeoffs are to some extent unavoidable) but the founders of the US felt sufficiently strongly about the whole thing that it got a mention in the Constitution... having crossed the Atlantic more than a few times, my conclusion is the US has made a choice which is congruent with other aspects of American life.