Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Your justice system is flawed, too. (Score 1) 1081

You are assigning causation where there is only correlation. That is a common logical fallacy. I am saying there is a correlation between being educated, being wealthy and discussing ethical theory. You are saying because someone is wealthy and well educated, they created ethical theory to maintain wealth.

You are inferring causation where there is none, and it seems to be based on your predisposition to dislike people with money.

Comment Re:Your justice system is flawed, too. (Score 1) 1081

This is a huge oversimplification of many concepts stemming from your predisposed views of the world.

Foremost, amoralism is systemic to the human condition. Rich people, poor people average people, all have the capacity for moral and immoral acts.

Secondly, ethics is always based on what someone else deems as right and wrong. Ethics is the code of conduct between one person and everyone else. Even if you decided what was right and wrong, the rest of the world would be subject to the right and wrong decided by someone else. It is a group effort.

Lastly, classical ethics for the most part was created by the rich and powerful. But that is because they were the educated, not because they were trying to take over the world. The uneducated, even today, don't sit around thinking about the fundamentals of ethical theory.

Comment Re:Your justice system is flawed, too. (Score 1) 1081

There are many classical ethical philosophies, which you clearly don't understand. Social contract isn't then end all be all of theories. If you warp one philosophy you tend to end up actually using another or a blend of several. Our current state is a mix of egoism, social contract and utilitarianism, all poorly implemented.

Blame the theory all you want, but it's only a fool who blames his tools.

Comment Re:Your justice system is flawed, too. (Score 1) 1081

What have you been smoking? Social contract theory is a philosophy; it's an idea. It was not perpetrated by some Illuminati conspiracy theory to keep people in check. Even within your own argument, you bash social contract theory in one paragraph, then praise its merits in the next based on the implementing class.

If you want to argue over the merits of an ethical philosophy, have some idea of what you are talking about: http://www.philosophybasics.co...

If you want to complain about the overbearing police state the US has become, that's ok to. But don't string big words together if you don't know what they mean.

Comment Re:Issue will be resolved... (Score 1) 347

That may be, but I posted my comment in rebuttal to this statement:

Big ISPs have a virtual monopoly on Broadband over more than 80% of the U.S. It's a de facto oligopoly, which free market -- as much as I believe in the concept -- won't fix. There IS a time for government regulation, and this is one of them.

Again, the reason cable companies have a monopoly is because of regulation, so how does more regulation fix the problem?

Slashdot Top Deals

Software production is assumed to be a line function, but it is run like a staff function. -- Paul Licker

Working...