Comment A real challenge (Score 2) 386
Would it be possible to publish a set of criteria that would prove beyond reasonable doubts that an effect is unexplained. As far as I know, nobody has passed the preliminary selection for the challenge and there is no set of rules or document.
One set of rule for example.
Selection of participants: The phenomena must be repeatable with more than 99% confidence and be demonstrated by at least 3 independent scientists. The work must have been published in peer review journal.
Test: The test must be performed on a TV stage with more than 99% confidence with 10 skeptics and/or expert magicians present.
Or something similar. There is nothing right now.
For me the current challenge is more like propaganda than wanting to actually know the truth.
A faculty scientist and radical empiricist at the University of California San Diego