Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment It's all about marijuana (Score 2) 314

The real problem is that security-related government jobs require security clearances and lie detector tests that exclude a large portion of geeks, in my opinion. They want to make sure you haven't done a bunch of drugs in the past 7 years, but for most smart geeks, that's the time they usually did their drugs. They need to relax the rules on some drugs if they want more talent.

Comment What is more important than abstract reasoning? (Score 1) 421

The post seems to say there is more to intelligence than abstract reasoning. How else do you differentiate Man and beast other than the ability for abstraction (aside from the ability to communicate it, I guess). Every other aspect of the human mind is exhibited in other animals, but we are the only ones able to understand our world as a set of abstract concepts. Abstraction is vital in our ability to teach our offspring, to create new tools, to find new strategies. Behaviors that take evolution millenia to develop can be conceptualized and executed in mere seconds by a capable human.

Comment Re:Over 70% of ADHD can be cured without drugs (Score 1) 487

You are making that number up because the studies show that medication is the only effective treatment for ADHD. Cognitive and Behavioral Therapy has been shown to have virtually no effect when compared to drugs. Furthermore, there is virtually no additional alleviation of symptoms when medication is combined with CBT. You can dream all you want, but you're just wrong.

Comment I've been taking Adderall for almost 13 years (Score 5, Insightful) 487

In high school, I had my own web development company and was an accomplished, award-winning saxophone player but I struggled getting the grades I should have been able to get for a reason that I couldn't understand. I was diagnosed with ADHD in 10th grade and set upon a journey involving virtually every drug recommended for the disorder. I settled upon Adderall and have been taking it ever since. Reading through the comments on this page, I find it amusing that everyone seems to have such a black and white opinion on the subject. I, on the other hand, really don't know what to think.

Studies show that nothing is more effective at treating ADHD than stimulants and cognitive therapy does virtually nothing without drugs. Furthermore, people who control their ADHD with medication are FAR more likely to avoid substance abuse than if they leave their condition untreated. I'm sure everyone knows a really smart kid in high school who smoked their life away on weed and never made anything of themselves. I know that I personally would have probably gone this route, as I was already heading in that direction. Finally, stimulants like Adderall haven't been shown to have any real long term health consequences and (contrary to popular belief) are not particularly addictive if taken as directed.

Anyone who has been to college in the past decade can tell you that Adderall can certainly help you cram for tests. Does that mean it gives them an advantage? I really don't think so. I've crammed for a lot of tests, and unless you're a business or mass communication major, you are not going to get an A by cramming. Try cramming a month's worth of organic chemistry in one night with some Adderall. You'll probably pass, but you definitely aren't getting an A. People get A's on tests by keeping up with the work. Not to mention the horrific day you have after cramming all night on speed. The biggest advantage I saw with Adderall was playing Quake 3, and even then there were people a lot better than me that used nothing but Mountain Dew.

I guess what I'm saying is that I think that people are overestimating the power of stimulants. Their biggest advantage is that you can stay up later, but if you don't take the drug regularly, you will also not be able to get to sleep. You'll also not eat enough and will probably have issues with sexual dysfunction. If that sounds like an unfair advantage to you, I don't know what to tell you.

Comment Re:mainly Heinlein (Score 1) 700

I recently re-read a lot of Heinlein books, including the Moon is a Harsh Mistress and found that I now see his writing for what it is. He is misogynistic, preachy, and focuses on polygamy and nudity obsessively and at length in several of his books. Even Stranger in a Strange Land turned absolutely retarded at about the halfway mark.

Comment The Information: A History, a Theory, a Flood (Score 1) 700

As an older computer engineer, I would bet that your schooling is obsolete and that you haven't been keeping up on current information theory. I found The Information: A History, a Theory, a Flood by James Gleick utterly fascinating. It is long-winded at times, but it changed the way I perceive the world and changed how I approach programming and developing systems. We are on the cusp of a revolution in computer science/information theory towards semantic systems and this book gives a great glimpse into current philosophy and theory.

Slashdot Top Deals

No man is an island if he's on at least one mailing list.

Working...