HAM radio has long irritated me -- because while I completely see the value in people forming clubs to learn to use it, and value in cooperation so the bands can be used constructively? I think getting federal govt. involved in it was a HUGE mistake.
So you don't think the federal government has any right to regulate the use of radio spectrum? I think you are gravely mistaken. Radio spectrum space is a national resource that needs to be managed at the federal level or chaos would be the result. Literally nothing would work like it does now. Your cell phone, your GPS receiver, your WiFi router, the radio in your car and a whole host of things would be hit or miss, if they worked at all. The FCC is necessary. In fact, it was the FCC that created CB, and at least initially they required a license if you where using it. So, like it or not, even on CB you are subject to FCC regulations about the equipment you use and how you use it. Not that they enforce them very well.
I don't care how "easy" the licensing has become. The idea I should have to earn (and pay for) a license before I have the privilege of transmitting over the airwaves disgusts me.
You do realize that the fees you are charged for taking the test are NOT collected for the FCC's coffers right? The FCC doesn't get a dime of the $15 test fees, but it goes to the VE organizations that print, distribute, mail, administer and file the paperwork related to the testing. It doesn't even go the guys/gals standing their monitoring you when you take the test, who grade the test and fill out the paperwork, they are all volunteers who do this for free. Which is what the Armature radio service is all about.
Plus, there is a *point* to what you need to learn here. RF is dangerous stuff at power levels legal for hams to use. You can harm yourself, your family and those that live around you if you don't know what you are doing. Proving you have at least SOME knowledge about what you are doing is a good idea. Also, spectrum is a finite resource, and if you don't know how to tune your radios and antennas or know what modulation techniques are suitable you are going to waste a whole lot of that resource.
But I think you totally ignore the *purpose* of ham radio,
(a) Recognition and enhancement of the value of the amateur service to the public as a voluntary noncommercial communication service, particularly
with respect to providing emergency communications.
(b) Continuation and extension of the amateur's proven ability to contribute to the advancement of the radio art.
(c) Encouragement and improvement of the amateur service through rules which provide for advancing skills in both the communication and technical
phases of the art.
(d) Expansion of the existing reservoir within the amateur radio service of trained operators, technicians, and electronics experts.
(e) Continuation and extension of the amateur's unique ability to enhance international goodwill.
(from 47 CFR Part 97, Paragraph 1 "Basis and Purpose")
I was always very interested in the hobby, even purchasing a hand-held HAM radio receiver at one time to play around with. But ultimately, I got into CB radio and sold the HAM gear, because it's more true to how I think it should all work.
When I used to listen to the "regulars" on the HAM bands, chatting, it struck me as largely a crowd of entitled, older men who felt self-important that they had this govt. issued call-sign to flaunt around.
I'm sure many others simply take HAM radio as a serious responsibility (ability to get communications through in major emergencies, etc.) -- and that's great. But I'd rather see CB radio expanded to be far more useful by turning over a bigger chunk of these licensed HAM bands for the general public. Even on existing CB, I've seen channel 9 monitored very efficiently by volunteers at local radio stations who path you through to emergency services if needed. No govt. licensing necessary to make that function.
Let me guess.. You purchased the HAM gear and just couldn't avoid the temptation to hit the transmit button and try and communicate with the guys you heard. And you got your nose out of joint because they won't talk to you because your "invented" callsign was obviously fake to them. I'll bet you don't yet know why they knew or why they wouldn't talk to you. If I'm even half right, is it any wonder they where not nice? You where breaking the law, using *their* repeater to do it, subjecting *them* to fines in the process. None of this you would understand though, because you didn't feel the need to know the material. Even if you didn't transmit, just listened, there is a method to how all this is done and a reason for the method that sounds "stuffy" to you, because it is the most effective way to communicate in emergency situations. Yea, we might be talking about the swimming pool or the latest radio we got with the last retirement check, but there are other people to talk to out there if you don't like the repeater you are on.
I'll challenge you. Go out and *get* your license THEN get on their repeater and ask for help and there are guys/gals out there who will be knocking down your door to help you get set up, loan you gear until you can afford your own, and providing training on how to be the most effective operator you can be. Heck, show up at one of their meetings even without a license and ask for help studying for the test, you will get LOTS of help. I know at least three guys in the club I'm in who will gladly arrange a class and a test session just for you, then likely get you set up and going when your ticket gets cut.
This is totally unlike my experience on CB. I've been totally ignored or just cussed at when asking for help, but I've rarely been helped in any meaningful way. But if you like that environment, do what suits you, just keep it legal.