Comment Re:In lost the will to live ... (Score 1) 795
You're also ignoring that a shocking number of people nowadays actually are mostly narcissistic sociopaths...Next time someone cuts you off in traffic
That's hyperbole. Cutting someone off in traffic is possibly a selfish act, depending on the larger situation, but it doesn't make a narcissist or a sociopath. We live in the least violent, most socially integrated period in the history of our species, and both conditions are probably more rare than ever before.
What if that person believed at that very moment that a higher power will make them pay for inconveniencing someone else unnecessarily? Would they recognize they're being an asshole and stop?
If they stop, it would only be out of fear of that "power." To recognize that what they are about to do is wrong, and choose not to do it, requires an internal experience of empathy or an again internal rational process which concludes the total costs of the act are greater than the total benefits.
The problem with religious justifications of ethics is that they are just that: post-facto rationalizations for previously committed acts. In reality, people perform acts based on their internal emotional experience in the relevant moment. They experience, unbidden, feelings of "good" or "bad" which influence the immediate decision making process. Whether or not the capacity for these feelings was instilled by evolution or by a god is not strictly relevant here.