Comment slashdot poster stupidity record shattered (Score 1) 2058
I've been on Slashdot for what 15ish years now... before there were user IDs.. anyway
I've always hated the supposedly free market capitalism anti-government crap espoused by the supposedly enlightened intellectual libertarians who hand around the "open source" movement. But this is the worst I have ever seen, and it proves they are not intellectuals, they are rabid dogmatists.
The fire department DOES need to get paid for fighting fires, and when a non-insured home is on fire the "putting out an actual fire" service fee will need to be much higher than the "putting out a hypothetical fire" insurance fee. But the service fee can be paid OUT OF POCKET, or by putting a LIEN on the house. The cost to put the fire out was WAY less than the value of the home, and refusing to put it out ends up being a net destruction of wealth (not to mention the lives of the pets inside).
At this point the worst libertards say "well they didn't pay the insurance, so tough", and it completely escapes their consideration that MAYBE just MAYBE the fire department could have charged them $5000 or $10000 to put out the fire. An intellectual would see that alternate payment system as a good and just possibility, but a dogmatist doesn't need to think that hard because they already have all the answers.
Any economic system that fails to protect wealth and watches it burn away will lead to a society with LESS WEALTH. The fire department may have saved $1000 by not putting out the fire, but the society lost 200 times that when the home and its contents were consumed. If you don't have enough brains to improve upon that result, even within the libertarian worldview then you are an idiot, not a legitimate intellectual that people should bother listening to.