Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Amazon Deleting 1984 Was a Warning... (Score 1) 450

In this case, your conclusion is flawed; here is why:

Premises:
1 Entity A is a bookseller
2 Entity B is a bookseller
3 Entity A would charge no more than $X for the book
4 Entity B would charge $X for the book
5 The method by which entity B gets the book in these examples is considered wrong.
(X can be 0)

Your example, physical book:
State 0:
* You have $X that you intend to spend to purchase the book
* Entity A has the book
* Entity B exists
State 1:
* You have $X that you intend to spend to purchase the book
* Entity B has the book
* Entity A no longer has the book
State 2:
* You have the book
* Entity B has $X
* Entity A does not have the book

What actually happened:
State 0:
* You have $X that you intend to spend to purchase the book
* Entity A has the book
* Entity B exists
State 1:
* You have $X that you intend to spend to purchase the book
* Entity A has the book
* Entity B has the book
State 2:
* You have the book
* Entity A has the book
* Entity B has the book and $X

In either case, I believe that the correct response is to move the $X from B to A, not to move the $X back from B to you and remove the book from you.
Entity A is upset because it didn't get the money/recognition from selling the book to you; moving the $X from B to A and letting you know addresses those things.

Obviously, if any of the premises are wrong, the conclusion changes.
If 1 is false, then the correct response in your case is to do exactly what Amazon did, and reverse the transaction. This may be true in the second case too, although I personally disagree.
If 2 is false, then the situation doesn't happen because entity B doesn't sell you the book.
If 3 is false, then the correct response is to give you the choice of paying the difference or reversing the transaction.
If 4 is false, then the situation is a bit more complicated, and is not related to what actually happened, so I'm not going to talk about it.
If 5 is false, then the correct response is to do nothing.

I'm confident that this is true for any thing, not just books, but I'm not certain.

Slashdot Top Deals

The use of money is all the advantage there is to having money. -- B. Franklin

Working...