Comment Re:No, not really (Score 1) 390
Plenty of popular novels were written in days or weeks. Michael Moorcock, for example
I take it he's a writer of romance novels?
Plenty of popular novels were written in days or weeks. Michael Moorcock, for example
I take it he's a writer of romance novels?
Here's the "Uncanny Valley" effect again. Fringe actually doesn't bother me because it's SO out there - to me it presents an expectation of "we're not even going to *try* to come close to the real world."
For this reason, I'm able to suspend disbelief without discomfort for Fringe; the "reality" is so cracked that I don't even try to compare it to real life.
This reminds me of the old joke:
Alice and Bob are camping when they get attacked by a hungry lion. Running away at top speed, Alice begins to overtake Bob. "We'll never be able to outrun it!" says Bob. Alice replies, "I don't need to outrun the lion - I only need to outrun YOU!"
In that sense, all the security any given person needs is just not to be low-hanging fruit.
It doesn't make sense to me when you say frequency-domain codecs cannot be perceptually transparent. That statement is general and absolute and is in contradiction to the experimental data.
If a codec is indistinguishable from the original by a given individual, it is by definition transparent - at least for that person, with that source material, on that system.
Absolute proof is not achievable in this situation, but I believe the extensive double-blind ABX tests on hydrogenaudio provide a reasonably convincing body of evidence in favor of general perceptual transparency of high-bitrate MP3 with most source material on most sound systems for most people.
Vague and dogmatic assertions about "known issues" are less convincing to me. If it is a question of human perception, which this is, then the way to get closer to the answer is to test it by observing humans, not by theorizing without experimenting.
There must be something in the brain that will make us stand and fight for our "side", even if it's in the wrong...
And THAT is exactly what politics in the US has devolved into.
"The four building blocks of the universe are fire, water, gravel and vinyl." -- Dave Barry