Comment Re:Well... (Score 1) 493
What about people with other health conditions who cannot tolerate the vaccine?
They would benefit in the event of an oubreak in there area. They could be notified directly that there was an outbreak in the area so that they could then decide to leave the hot zone before becoming infected. I don't think anyone is claiming vaccines should be administered to those at high risk for adverse events (egg allgies, or previous adverse reactions to similar vaccines). However, unvaccinated people do pose a risk not only to themselves, but to others. Being able to mitigate those risks would help everyone.
To be clear, I approve of something like this for the US (where I live) but only if the list is maintained by health officals only. I see no reason for this to be publicly available information. I have no business knowing if you are vaccinated, but the WHO or CDC does in the event of a legitimate risk in your area.
It should also certainly be possible for somebody to make a request for a copy of this record with, at most, only a little more trouble than one can get a copy of their normal medical records.
Beyond a certain critical mass of vaccinations, additional vaccinations are subject to diminishing returns.
Very true, but that critical mass is around 95%. The original article makes it clear that in Canada, the vaccination rates are nowhere near that number. Articles I've read in the US place the rates below that number as well. Especially in regions where non-medical vaccination abstentions are high (religious groups, Wealthy communities suffering from the misconception that vaccines are related to autism, etc.).
Ironically enough, the vaccine that this misconception is most often associated with, the MMR vaccine, is actually one that prevents autism. (One of the known causes is in utero exposure to rubella, and the vaccine needs to be gotten before pregnancy.) Getting to critical mass also basically means that as few exceptions as possible ought to be made, especially as we learn more about the immune system and how long immunity actually lasts (or doesn't)--which is a reason to be wary of vaccines that promise most of their payoff decades down the line until it's been around for decades.