> So we shouldn't have any laws then because they *might* be unjust or because law enforcement could potentially overstep their authority?
We shouldn't have unjust laws. We should have measures in place to prevent and punish abuse of power by the government.
> This site broke the law.
Which law?
> They got shut down.
No, they didn't. The site isn't hosted in the US, and is legal in the country in which it's hosted. The US domain registrars revoked their .com and .org domains.
> They happened to have a forum. If you have a church in a meth lab you can't claim freedom of religion when the building is seized.
Feel free to tell us which law Rojadirecta breaks when they link to other sites. Then feel free to tell us why US laws should apply to a Spanish website.