why all this fuss about Star Wars. The movies were good when I was a 10 year old. Now they are unwatchable and boring to me.
Because they're cinema history. I showed Star Wars to my artsy tenant, pausing every now and then to explain the importance of different scenes - important not just in story context, in EU context, but in real world context. Doing that, he could then appreciate Star Wars for what it has done.
- Before Star Wars, space fantasy was very bland. Aliens were variants of humans, the the extent that people struggled to accept even Mr Spock's pointy ears. Most Star Wars sentients still are humanoid (and that lack of imagination bothers me slightly), but for the 70's/80's Star Wars aliens were very "out there".
- Having a cliffhanger ending until the next movie (Is Vader really Luke's father?!?) was a first as well. Now we're used to it.
- Big budget spending in fantasy movies. Until then, big budgets did not go to such a movie because the thinking was that not enough people would watch it to cover the high costs. The thinking is a little different now. Now we get lots of big budget space, sword'n sorcery and superhero movies.
(I think with the prequels, Lucas was still stuck in his old thinking that big budget special effects make the movie, whereas we've got used to it, expect it, and now want the story to be compelling.)
- Making a fantasy movie into an epic movie. Now most are, or at least try to be. Compare Star Wars to anything else made until then.
In short, Star Wars did for space fantasy what Lord of the Rings did for sword'n sorcery literature: opened new ground and opened the genre to the masses
Sure, Star Wars may not be so great in context of what else is out there now, though it's not that bad either. But put it into context of it's time...