Submission + - Cloning, astroturfing... and who is Rachel Ray?
Keith_Beef writes: So, I accidentally hit carriage return after only typing in the string "news" in the URL field... and Verizon took me to a list of pages and out of curiosity I opened the first two links in new tabs.
Well, I was treated to a very nice story, or was it two stories... about a woman, or was it two women? Anyway, she (they) is (are) named "Grace Connell from ," [sic] and "Morgan Johnson from ," [sic]...
Or at least, the woman (women) was (were) from no place until I temporarily enabled Javascript... and then magically both stories announced the woman in question to be from Rutherford, NJ...
Now what is even stranger, or maybe not, is that these two women look like identical twins! Wow!
You know by now what is going on. Some advertising blurb, dressed up as a "true life story" with a bit of Javascript to sniff my IP address that gets somehow mapped to a town not too far from my address, based on Verizon's block of addresses.
Look for yourselves:
http://www.gracesdiet.com/?t202id=42143
http://www.morgansdiet.com/?t202id=32041
Now, how is this kind of thing viewed by the FTC? Surely these two pages fall foul of the "truth-in-advertising rules", no?
http://www.brandingstrategyinsider.com/2008/01/truth-in-advert.html
Apparently, the FDA has bigger teeth than the FTC, because whoever registered (with NameCheap.com) the two domains gracesdiet.com and morgansdiet.com feels it necessary to put FDA disclaimers in page footers, but doesn't feel morally obliged to refrain from making up spurious "real-life stories" in order to sell dietary supplements of dubious usefulness...
So, what is to be done? Is there any hope? Or should I just go and buy shares in the Brawndo Corporation right now?
Well, I was treated to a very nice story, or was it two stories... about a woman, or was it two women? Anyway, she (they) is (are) named "Grace Connell from
Or at least, the woman (women) was (were) from no place until I temporarily enabled Javascript... and then magically both stories announced the woman in question to be from Rutherford, NJ...
Now what is even stranger, or maybe not, is that these two women look like identical twins! Wow!
You know by now what is going on. Some advertising blurb, dressed up as a "true life story" with a bit of Javascript to sniff my IP address that gets somehow mapped to a town not too far from my address, based on Verizon's block of addresses.
Look for yourselves:
http://www.gracesdiet.com/?t202id=42143
http://www.morgansdiet.com/?t202id=32041
Now, how is this kind of thing viewed by the FTC? Surely these two pages fall foul of the "truth-in-advertising rules", no?
http://www.brandingstrategyinsider.com/2008/01/truth-in-advert.html
Apparently, the FDA has bigger teeth than the FTC, because whoever registered (with NameCheap.com) the two domains gracesdiet.com and morgansdiet.com feels it necessary to put FDA disclaimers in page footers, but doesn't feel morally obliged to refrain from making up spurious "real-life stories" in order to sell dietary supplements of dubious usefulness...
So, what is to be done? Is there any hope? Or should I just go and buy shares in the Brawndo Corporation right now?