Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:One-size-fits-all, a way to sabotage your app (Score 1) 337

The author of the app would rarely hear a complaint. They may see a download of a free app. What they wouldn't see is the uninstall or lack of use of the app and the competitor's app that gets downloaded as an alternative.

Who would hear about an app that didn't look or feel "right", or that lacked expected platform specific functionality? That would be friends, coworkers, classmates, etc. Rarely the author. As I said, its word of mouth that makes or breaks apps.

Comment Re:One-size-fits-all, a way to sabotage your app (Score 1) 337

What is being said is that it puts a modern app at a competitive disadvantage in the market. And Qt on iOS gives you that. You don't notice any difference. Hence your argument is simply wrong.

Numerous users of QT based apps say otherwise. Even when QT is using native widgets instead of emulating them.

Plus there is the whole issue of platform specific functionality and features that QT does not support.

Comment Re:Just use OpenBSD, for crying out loud! (Score 1) 91

There are several other problems. 1) When you come back to enter more data and expect the fields to be populated (the form takes a day or two to fill out the first time).

Again, fill out the form on the public side. Completely filled out. It doesn't need to got into the database until then.

2) When you need access to something and the manager of that element has to look at your file to approve it.

(a) The people who need to access it can be on the air gapped side, analysts and such.
(b) One person's data can be extracted from the database, walked across the gap, and sent to someone who needs it. The point of the gap is to isolate the database with everyone's records, and the monitor/supervise data coming from and being sent to public networks. Individual records being worked on at a given moment can outside. Expose of data being minimized.

3) When you get a new security manager and they have to approve it.

Such people can work on the air gapped side.

Your basically taking us back to the paper office days. In that time it was really easy to not put two and two together because cross referencing information was really hard.

Again, I think the people doing the cross referencing, analysis, etc can be on the air gapped side. They can be a team with members from all relevant departments and agencies.

Comment Re:Why 8-bit 8051 over 32-bit ARM ? (Score 1) 56

From my work in the consumer electronics industry designing embedded chips, fractions of a penny add into big numbers when multiplied by millions or billions of parts. See the PIC. I don't know what the industry is dong today, but 15 years ago people were talking about building hundreds of devices for a penny. An internet connected lightbulb doesn't need to be that capable. ON/OFF/BURNOUT are it's three required states.

Yeah, for a commodity product that competes on nothing other than price. However IOT devices may compete on functionality as well and/or start out as niche products not massively deployed products. I think your point may be more true of later generation devices than it is for initial generations.

Comment If modern more familiar CPU has a low enough cost (Score 1) 56

if you have spare cycles and are iot, you did it wrong

I'm not so sure. What if an ultra-low-power ARM's cost is in the ballpark of an 8051? One might save on the software development and maintenance side by using a more modern and familiar CPU.

Look at desktop/laptop CPUs. They are grossly overpowered for many users. Why would iot devices follow a similar pattern if the costs are right?

Comment Re:Air gaps allow for data input and output ... (Score 1) 91

Why is the entire file necessary for the interview? A relevant excerpt, only what the applicant claims with respect to Joe, can be walked back across that air gap and sent to the regional office. The interview results then get walked past the air gap and merged/appended to the file. Naturally what really gets walked across is a large number of excerpts and data to merge/append.

Whether it's all of the file or part of the file is irrelevant, since the transmission time via USPS or UPS or FedEx is the same (per company obviously) whether you're sending a single page or a whole stack of pages. Your point about malware is well-taken though.

Apologies for being not being clear but the fragment of a single file would be sent electronically via a network. The point is that the entire database does not need to be exposed and vulnerable to a single breach.

Comment Re:Just use OpenBSD, for crying out loud! (Score 1) 91

The SF-86 is an online form. How are you going to airgap that?

Entry occurs on the public side of the gap. An applicant's data gets transferred to electronic media and walked across the gap. The applicant's data then get merged into the air gapped database that holds *everyone's* data.

Remember, before cat-5 cables we had station wagons loaded with tapes and it worked quite well. :-)

Comment Air gaps allow for data input and output ... (Score 1) 91

If you air-gap that system you have to hire someone to either run OCR scans or enter all that data by hand into the database.

Or someone does a malware scan of electronic media and if all clear they walk the media past the air gap.

Let's say your character witness is Joe Schmuckatelly who lives in California and you live in Nebraska. It's easier and less expensive for the regional office in Nebraska to put the file on the network and request the regional office in California to interview Joe.

Why is the entire file necessary for the interview? A relevant excerpt, only what the applicant claims with respect to Joe, can be walked back across that air gap and sent to the regional office. The interview results then get walked past the air gap and merged/appended to the file. Naturally what really gets walked across is a large number of excerpts and data to merge/append.

In short air gaps allow for electronic data input and output, just in a very controlled and monitored manner.

Comment The IRS can reorganize its internal spending (Score 5, Insightful) 91

If Congress again passes a requirement for departments to do something but refuses to fund it then the executive branch can't do anything.

Not true. The agency can cut spending elsewhere to implement the requirement. Which is what Congress wants the IRS to do, while the IRS want to use the excuse of no new funding to maintain things as they are. It all just theatre.

Comment Re:A truth is a truth, even if unoriginally expres (Score 1) 222

nadaou was quite clearly referring to the AC's use of a specific cliche ... In any event, refuting the claim "using cliches is stupid" isn't the same thing as rufuting "using cliches weakens an argument" or "cliches contain no truth".

Actually my criticism included that specific cliche, and my later examples referred to that specific cliche, and demonstrating a kernel of truth in that specific cliche refutes the assertion that the cliche is stupid. Its merely unimaginative.

From http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/cliche

So what? From Wikipedia

an expression, idea, or element of an artistic work which has become overused to the point of losing its original meaning or effect, even to the point of being trite or irritating, especially when at some earlier time it was considered meaningful or novel.

I never said one definition is superior to another, I merely pointed out that *some* definitions indicate that the use of cliches could be meaningless and therefore detrimental to a coherent argument.

Actually it seems a quite rare definition, possibly erroneous, buy hey its wiki. The wiki references include several dictionaries and they agree with the loss of impact. The wiki editor apparently lifted the definition from a literary device website. So we can go with dictionary, after dictionary, after dictionary, after dictionary, or some guy's literary device website.

Yeah, I really did check 4 dictionaries, I thought maybe I got lucky with the first but all 4 agreed.

Slashdot Top Deals

You knew the job was dangerous when you took it, Fred. -- Superchicken

Working...