Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:In other words... (Score 2) 284

Something's been troubling me recently about the whole "corporations are people" thing. If corporations are people, what's to prevent corporations from running for public office? Suppose a corporation was founded in the US at least 35 years ago, could that corporation run for President? It's the logical (and frightening) conclusion to the "corporations are people" argument. How long until the companies stop merely buying candidates and instead BECOME the candidates?

You've fallen victim to propaganda.

There are many people who use the term "corporations are people" because it's absurd, the desire is to create a backlash against a strawman. Corporations are not "people". Corporations are "persons". There's an enormous difference.

I'll explain a few things.

The constitution references three types of being with rights.

  • Person
  • The People
  • Citizen(s)

Some of us belong to all three categories.

A person can be a living human being or a corporate person. Corporations are "persons" under the law, not people.

Only a human being can be a citizen. Corporations are not and can not be citizens.

The people are all of the citizens of the country, collectively and individually. This includes corporations, individual human beings as well as groups of corporations and human beings.

A requirement for for holding a constitutionally defined office is citizenship. One can not be a Senator, a Representative or the President unless one is a citizen. To be a citizen, one must be a human being.

Have you ever noticed that no one has ever sued the dog that bit him? If a car's brakes fail and you're struck, you don't sue the car. You sue the owner and/or the manufacturer. Same reason.

Corporate personhood isn't controversial or dangerous in any way. In fact, it's the very reason for incorporation. To "incorporate" is to "bring together into one (legal)body".

Non-persons can not be the object of legal proceedings. Non-persons can not own property. Non-persons do not have legal responsibilities.

What would the point of forming a corporation be if it weren't a separate being?

LK

Slashdot Top Deals

Anyone can make an omelet with eggs. The trick is to make one with none.

Working...