Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Philosophy is fundamental (Score 1) 515

Ah, fair enough. I should be more circumspect when making sweeping exclusions of usage. This means, of course, that one can throw a javelin wide, and GGGP's claim is still wrong, and so is mine.

Hmmm... if we're allowed to set porkchop = 7, then we can (sort of) answer both questions. But we still won't know what the answers mean.

Comment Re:Philosophy is fundamental (Score 1) 515

Agreed (although there are multiple notions of dimensionality at play here). The trajectory of a thrown javelin can be regarded as one-dimensional for many purposes, but if we look closely enough we find that the javelin itself has width. Even if we neglect its width, it has length; and as its velocity is generally not exactly parallel to its axis, it will sweep out a two-dimensional surface as it flies.

To say, as GP does, that the trajectory of a thrown javelin is "inherently ... one-dimensional" is to regard the simplest approximation as more fundamental than the physical reality -- i.e. confusing the map for the territory.

In my book, the reason why one cannot throw a javelin wide is much simpler: "wide" is not an adverb that can meaningfully modify the verb "throw".

Comment Re:Philosophy is fundamental (Score 1) 515

Assuming you mean "above the 98th percentile", the required storage would be reduced by a factor of 50, of course. Huge / 50 = still huge.

Forget percentiles; maybe we can just store responses for the N most common sentences, where N is a million or a billion or something. Depending on who administers the Turing test, the philosopher may have been right.

Comment Re:What's up with /. Headlines? (Score 1) 389

Certainly. In English we use nouns as adjectives all the time, and I'm trying to decide whether one of these "is" a noun or an adjective. Perhaps it depends on what the meaning of "is" is.

Maybe we can agree on noun present-participle noun-adjunct noun past-participle noun?

Still, in a discussion of grammatically ambiguous headlines, it may in fact be more relevant that the basic nature of the word "security" is nounish. One has to parse at least part of the headline in order to determine that it's being used adjectivally. In this particular case that's not the difficult part of the headline, but in another case, such as the good example that I'm too lazy to construct right now, it might be.

Slashdot Top Deals

Work is the crab grass in the lawn of life. -- Schulz

Working...