Comment Re:I agree with this change (Score 1) 248
"Most of us writers aren't petty jerks who enjoy tearing other people down undeservedly."
Speak for yourself.
More seriously, consider your use of "undeservedly".
Writers are a lot more critical of writing than the average reading public. Any good writer has some experience with critiquing other work and getting her own work critiqued. Any good writer will have an eye for what she considers errors in the way sentences are strung, scenes are described, point of view, etc., etc. I've been in critique groups. A lot of writers slam things just because they would write them differently.
I said "any good writer" because these days it's easy to publish books without going through and editor, and this means people who think their writing is perfect and can't benefit from comments are out there, and they will likely slam other books with less of a rational basis.
Either way, writers aren't to be trusted when it comes to how enjoyable the book is to the less discerning non-writers.