Comment Re:Nintendo "Corporate Social Responsibility": (Score 1) 100
What legal precedent do they set if they allow a guy to just flat out reimplement their game?
Actually, none. Copyrights aren't compromised by allowing infringements (unlike trademarks).
I agree with your other points though. Nintendo's position is reasonable. (Ignoring the copyright-duration debate, which is a separate issue.)
This isn't the first time we've seen this sort of response. Both fan remake projects of Chrono Trigger received Cease and Desist letters.