Well, the problem with this is that the idiots refusing vaccines aren't just putting themselves at risk.
If it was just they and their offspring would become ill? Hey, run wild. You've taken yourselves out of the gene pool and we don't care. That's your damned problem for a choice you made.
But that isn't what happens. Someone else gets sick.
Which means if you refuse to get vaccinated and then help to spread disease you should be liable for that. Like criminally liable.
If it was as simple as the herd doing without the ones who wouldn't get vaccinated, it would be an easy choice. What they really end up doing is endangering other people.
Which means they aren't solely the ones in danger by their own stupidity, and they should be refused access to places like schools and jobs so they don't make others ill due to their own stupid.
The person, that refused the vaccine and got sick, got the disease from someone else. So does that someone else also get charged criminally?
And if the person, that refused the vaccine and got sick, how would the disease affect anyone else except people that were not vaccinated?
I would think people like you, would think this to be a self solving problem.