Comment Re:most people arent wired for math (Score 1) 427
Probably you can do pre-7th grade math in one year, but you do not have much more time. With the beginning of puberty, many things suddenly become more interesting than learning new math.
I am working with selected -- so called gifted -- students of different age on math problems. I have given the same problem to 3rd grade and 7th grade students with the 7th grade students achieving not much more within 90 minutes than the 3rd grade students -- the problem did use knowledge from schools. The schools have failed in my opinion. Working on a different problem that involved some more rigorous proves (existence of Euler path'), the 7th grade students achieved more than the 3rd grade students on average (some exceptional 3rd grade student got most of it).
Either the article is right and the first six years of math education are more or less wasted even on the most skilled students -- or it is simply not the right approach that is used in school. As long as we do not teach "math" in school up to the high school level but only "computation", there are just cooking recipes, which tend to get boring, especially if the applications are flawed, too.
I have seen 4th grade students formulating proves by contradiction. Abstract thinking is possible in elementary school. I have seen many adults with university degree that fail on negating "C follows from (A or B)".
3rd grade students tend to be more open than 7th grade students, if you tell them that math without proves is no math at all -- because they have seen less so-called math.
The problems is that we do not teach math in elementary school at all!