There are other parts of the sate with similar issues, and from a macro perspective, for the last 3 years: the population of California in 2023 was 38,965,193, a 0.19% decline from 2022, the population of California in 2022 was 39,040,616, a 0.27% decline from 2021, the population of California in 2021 was 39,145,060, a 0.91% decline from 2020. These numbers are juxtaposed with a positive growth rate 1959 to 2022 when California’s average rate of population growth was 1.52 percent. In addition, as a whole, the nation continues to see population growth (although it is slowing). So while everything might all be smelling roses in CA, it's growth rate has declined over the last decade (losing a congressional seat in 2020) and is now in negative territory. These are just facts, although you can mock them all you want as right wing talking points, but something odd is going on...