Comment Re:I think the plaque works (Score 1) 349
There are two topics in the post. There's the example of the Pioneer plaque and the example of the Wikipedia edtors. And I agree in both instances... this is something that can't be overthought. In the case of Wikipedia, it's primary function is to provide information for humans... who know all about humans, so the picutre is really a formality. We all know about racial, cultural, socioeconomic differences, etc. So it really doesn't matter one little bit what photo is up there because it is just a placeholder for something we all know and understand.
As for the Pioneer plaque, on first contact all you want is the aliens to know it was the things that walk on two legs and look roughly like these pair that sent this. We just don't want them going to the giraffes or penguins, right? So again, complex human concepts are unimportant. In one case because we all understand them and it is meant for us, in the other because it isn't meant for us and they won't undertsand them anyway.