Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Life is complex (Score 1) 334

I've always thought, rather than have revision-upon-revision-upon-revision, so that you have to dig through 20 different bills to arrive at the final document, they should just republish the whole U.S. Code with the changes made. That way you only need to look at one document - the final one. It's not as if we're running out of electrons or paper.

I don't know about the U.S. Code but lawmakers all around the world do this already. Representatives vote for the "patch", but citizens only have to read the final document.

Comment Re:Life is complex (Score 1) 334

Let's look at an example, shall we? I picked a bill from govtrack.us: Respect for Marriage Act of 2009.

The bill would change the United States Code. You would not have to know the "Respect for Marriage Act" at all, you just have to know the United States Code.

My point: law makers use a kind of revisioning system already. The Respect for Marriage Act is like a proposed patch for the United States Code.

Comment Re:Life is complex (Score 1) 334

I guess the kernel source code and 100 pages bills are the same in this aspect. You don't need to know every little regulation in every field and in every part of the process. You have elected representatives who have to deal with complex legal issues. The 1000 pages are simply not relevant to you, but you should if you get health coverage and who has to pay for it. It is relevant for you that there is no "death panel". It is relevant for you if you can go to a doctor of your choice.

Comment Re:What would you gain? (Score 1) 334

I'm not a citizen in the US, but in many countries bills ake allready like patches.

If you want to change the law "Everybody must pay one dollar" to "Everybody must pay two dollars" you will not pass the whole law again, you will pass another bill that says that "one dollar" is replaces by "two dollars".

This way, the bills get huge - but the actual law is far less voluminous.

Comment Re:If the legal code is too confusing (Score 1) 334

So instead what winds up happening is the men and women voting for the law don't understand the law themselves.

That is an issue: Law makers habe to understand the decisions they are making. Of course not everybody has the knowledge to evaluate evry single consequence of every law, but the representatives have to keep the control.

Comment Life is complex (Score 3, Insightful) 334

A few thousand people in the whole world can really understand the source code of the linux kernel. Why would Linus make it so complicated? Is this "openness" just another prank? No, some things are complex. To make laws is a highly complex issue, Of course, there are many problems with the processes of law making - but just simplyfying the language would not do any good.

Slashdot Top Deals

Top Ten Things Overheard At The ANSI C Draft Committee Meetings: (5) All right, who's the wiseguy who stuck this trigraph stuff in here?

Working...