Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Not sure about the whole essay, but... (Score 2) 1122

Sorry, nobody is trying to silence him? The general consensus is that this guy should fired for expressing this opinion. You can agree or disagree with that, but I don't know how you get to suggesting nobody is trying to silence him. Why does anyone want him fired? Especially people who don't work at google?

Comment Re:Not sure about the whole essay, but... (Score 1) 1122

I understand your point, and it looks to me like he is criticizing a rather unique HR policy focus at the company as misguided and unfair. And in my comment I said this guy's career is over, whether he knows it yet or not. The smart thing to do would be to shut up. But that doesn't mean that he also doesn't have a valid point that there is something wrong with needing to shut up.

Comment Re:Not sure about the whole essay, but... (Score 1) 1122

> The goal is not to force people to become engineers, which he actually
> suggests is happening at one point. The goal is to help people do the
> things they want to do.

Well, that is really the question, isn't it. If everyone could do what they wanted to do, would we see equal representation of gender in fields like software engineering? This movement believes yes. I am skeptical. And I have see studies suggesting that as choice of career increases (e.g. wealthier countries with more freedom and opportunity), certain aggregate gender preferences express themselves more not less.

This just doesn't seem nearly as settled as people like to say it is. Even in this thread I got a reply that pretty much said anyone expressing other opinions are just factually wrong and can be safely ignored. That's valid for people running around saying the earth is flat, but is this really in the same category of certainty? It is quite a claim to suggest there are no gender career preferences. It wasn't that long ago that I was in PSY college classes where we learned quite a bit about differences between genders (in aggregate) that would be pretty reasonably expressed in career choices.

Science moves on and maybe all that as been "debunked" as has been claimed here. But this degree and pace of change in understanding is not what I would expect from a settled matter.

Comment Not sure about the whole essay, but... (Score 5, Insightful) 1122

One point where the author is spot on is the overwhelming efforts to silence any other viewpoints. Loom no further than the response to this memo. On twitter, a prominent tech entrepreneur said he thinks the real problem isn't the memo's content but that the author thought it was okay to share it at a place like Google. Isn't that exactly the point the author makes?

I also found interesting his point about how we feel differently about seeking 50-50 gender representation in manual labor occupations and work related deaths.

These topics are worthy of discussion. The "we must get girls to code" push always seemed worthy of skepticism. But there is no real debate in this area, and raising questions gets you labeled unfairly and possibly fired.

One thing is for sure: this guy's career is over. He will be doxxed by some news org who apparently does remember how to do investigative journalism when it comes to random civilians expressing a politically incorrect opinion. And the pitchforks will come out from the SJWs and no company -- certainly google -- wants to get mixed up in that PR nightmare. Game over, bro. Hope it was worth it.

Comment Re:Batteries and Control systems are expensive (Score 1) 494

You are very confused. Micro-inverter setups are more expensive than central inverter setups. You can't just compare the cost of one micro-inverter with the cost of one central inverter. And I thought we were talking about charge controllers. This is exactly my issue with the vast majority of "green energy advocates" who apparently love green energy so much they have never actually used it themselves. But you're all experts because you read some articles. Well, turns out you learn a lot of details that really matter when you setup a system for yourself.

Slashdot Top Deals

He has not acquired a fortune; the fortune has acquired him. -- Bion

Working...