Comment Re:Single streets (Score 1) 160
Chicago had the reverse experience. The main shopping street (State Street) was turned into a pedestrian mall and it essentially destroyed the city center. State Street wasn't an important traffic route (Michigan Avenue is a far larger and more important north/south street and only a few blocks away) but something about the lack of traffic made the area feel like a bad suburban mall rather than a vital part of the city. The major retail outlets eventually failed (part of this was due to larger trends in retailing, but accelerated along this street) and the whole area became filled with cheap tchotchke shops, empty storefronts and the homeless.
In the early 2000s, the second Mayor Daley decided to revert it back into a standard street. The street almost immediately revived. Again, there were some other trends helping with this (a push to have more people living in the Loop, redevelopment of an empty lot) but much of it was simply due to returning the "dynamism" of a street that had car traffic. State Street is once again a major shopping and dining destination and it has also revitalized several of the streets around it.