Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Something is in a given place and on a given time (Score 1) 536

Merkel's statement is correct within the framework of the German constitution and German law.
It is wrong, tho, within the framework of the USA constitution and law.

Which is "morally correct"? I'm not qualified to state. Specially since moral is ultimately individual.

However, a law can only regulate a constitutional right (or guarantee) if the constitution grants the law powers to do so, which is not the case here. Twitter's (and other's) decision is perfectly compatible with the USA Constitution and law.

"Oh", you might say, "it should be different!". Ok, there are constitutional means to change it. The constitution can me reformed via amendments. There as rules in place for that.

What you cannot do is apply one country's rules to another, one country's law to another, one country's constitution to another. Even if you think said country's constitution is better.

So, should things be different? Considering I'm the ones that defend that human rights should be horizontally applicable, then yes, they should be different. The US constitution should be amended to cover that horizontalization of human rights, which would also deal with several other issues. However, until that new amendment is in place, the current rule of law should be applicable.

If you think things should be different, make sure to exercise your civic right and talk to your representative about making changes.

Twitter's actions were right (within the law and and compatible with the constitution of the country they exist).

PS. Yes, I'm a lawyer with a masters in constitucional law.. No, this is not legal advice.

Comment Re:Marketing stunt (Score 4, Informative) 339

That is not how antitrust laws work.
This is 100% a marketing stunt.

PS: Yes, I AM a lawyer with a masters in constitutional law. No, this is not legal advice, since you didn't pay me.

Did you read the complaint?

The first 4 pages, including "NATURE OF THE ACTION", which are enough to show minimum legal grounds.
I know we are on slashdot, but I wouldn't have commented without reading at least that much.

Comment Re:Marketing stunt (Score 5, Informative) 339

It is only possible to have an issue if you can show monopoly practices. Thus, you could, very weakly, make an antitrust case between facebook and twitter for cancelled accounts.
On the other hand, AWS service is a completely different issue. It is like alleging anti competitive practices between a gas station and a bakery.
Because that is the hearth of the antitrust laws: to stop anticompetitive practices that lead to monopolies.
No yeah, nothing to do with AWS.
Also, since they were booted for repeated and clear violations of terms of service that are both legally sound and are not restrictive of otherwise permissive actions, the motivation for the boot is clearly demonstrated. For they to have an antitrust case regarding facebook and twitter they would have to show that those terms had the direct intent or indirect result of reducing competition. Which they clearly are not.

I'm sorry if I'm being vague. I'm trying my best to avoid lawyer-speak.

Comment Re:It's not a jammer, it's a shield (Score 2, Funny) 198

I was thinking there is no way this is not satire. Just some comic playing a funny one. I mean, have people read the website? It is amazingly funny.

Then I remembered Depak Chopra.

Dark times when you are not sure if this level of bs is a joke (if it is, kudos) or someone actually conning other people.

Comment Not paying enough attention to him (Score 5, Insightful) 580

Trump will fight anyone that opposes him. Anyone who threatens to steal the spotlight for a second.
This is 50% ego and 50% wanting to blame someone else for his blunders.
He had the information and failed to act on it. He has the information now and is saying business will reopen.
This has nothing to do with the many failures by the WHO (nothing new there, there are books and books on all their mistakes during the H1N1 pandemic) and everything to do with Trump.

Slashdot Top Deals

I tell them to turn to the study of mathematics, for it is only there that they might escape the lusts of the flesh. -- Thomas Mann, "The Magic Mountain"

Working...