Comment Re:Visual Programming Has Been a 20-Year Failed Ex (Score 1) 876
Visual code generators have existed for two decades, most famous is the Rational product. I've never met a developer or read an unbiased article claiming that the code generators have helped. Usually they say it just leads to ugly code and high maintenance overhead to maintain the diagrams. In natural language, why haven't photos and videos replaced words? It's because words are still the best way to express precise and complex logic. Now, it's up to the writer to express complex logic in a series of simple steps that a reader can understand, or to write in a convoluted way.
What about examples like www.genexus.com, www.windev.com or www.velneo.com ?
Despite not being 'famous', they are pretty succesful, in the sense that users are ahppy with them, and such users know 3GL languages and HATE to think working again in the 3GL way.
In my personal experience, I considers myself more a software architect than a programmer, and any of such 3 tools is a far better options for me than horrible ( compared to such 3 tools, regarding productivity) tools VisualStudio, Netbeans or Eclipse.
Software architects with real knowledge, can take a lot of advantage of such tools , I don't understand how people writes about supposed 'limitations', I hope they explain what are they talking about, perhaps they talk about cases equivalent in construction of giving an imaginary rapid-house-building tool to blue-collar workers without engineering and/or architecture knowledge?