Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:No (Score 1) 74

I'm not a regular user of reddit. I do have an account on the site but i don't browse it; i end up visiting reddit because of google searches. From what i've seen i think the quality of the posts and comments on reddit is poor. The signal-to-noise ratio is pretty low and it's a toxic waste dump. What kind of value is there for machine learning and AI training?

The value is that many of many of the topics on Reddit are not discussed anywhere else. It isn't that the data is good. It is the only data available.

Comment Re:Will it be enough to inspire a worthy compeitor (Score 1) 86

The major issues are:

No reordering of threads so you get the "first" posts stay on top for the lifetime, even if they're low quality. This tends to drive the discussion more than it needs to.

Only posting or Moderating. I can see the thought behind it, but it doesn't really make sense in practice unless the community is the exact right size. Either the community is large enough that there are more moderators to balance things out or the community is small and it reduces the moderation/posting because people can't do both.

This is necessary. If you allow people to moderate and post, people will routinely downvote comments that disagree with their own comments. This happens all the time on Reddit. Slashdot forces users to choose to between arguing their points (and generally getting wrapped up in their own viewpoints) and being the quality filter.

Similarly, random moderation is just a hinderance. I guess it goes with the rarely used meta-moderation, but that depends a lot on user interaction to work.

Random moderation is also necessary. Moderation should be an occasional privilege not another channel to participate in the thread as it is on Reddit. If volume is slow, as happens on Soylent, frequency of having mod points can be increased or we can accept that if traffic low, very little moderation is needed.

Reddit is hopelessly overmoderated. Redundant posts that express popular opinions are scored way up. Mildly descenting comments with real information and mod'd down to oblivion.

Too many moderation categories. It could probably be reduced to just 3 which would basically be: Good, Bad, Funny

Also necessary. The Slashdot system forces people to think about why they are moderating and expressly omits "disagree". Almost all moderation on Reddit is "agree" and "disagree".

Comment Re:Enshittification (Score 1) 86

It has. The platform dies. For large heaps of crap (like Microsoft), that may take decades, but for Reddit?

But Reddit is already manure and has been for... I'm not sure. Has it ever not been manure? And yet it persists. I'm not sure why. It doesn't have the strong network effect of eBay.

Comment Re:Will it be enough to inspire a worthy compeitor (Score 1) 86

Slashdot's moderation system is pretty garbage, especially for smaller communities

Compared to what? It is far superior to what Reddit uses despite being created several years before Reddit was founded. I'm not say that Slashdot moderation is perfect and enough time has elapsed that someone must have a better solution but If Slashdot is "garbage" than Reddit moderation is "toxic nuclear waste". Still an improvement.

Comment Re:Will it be enough to inspire a worthy compeitor (Score 1) 86

What would a worthy competitor actually look like?

One easy thing would be to clone Slashdot's moderation system. Or even improve on it. I mean, it has only been 25 years.

Allowing photos in the comments would also be helpful for image heavy groups, albeit less profound that fixing the current group think exaggerating moderation system.

Maybe even resurrect Usenet's hierarchy so it becomes easier to find appropriate groups.

Comment Brief window to find suitable jobs (Score 1) 266

"If you come out of school and work for a couple of years as waiter in a restaurant and apply for a college-level job, the employer will look at that work experience and not see relevance,"

While true, this is also another factor. Companies that fire fresh grads generally only want FRESH grads. The graduate fails to find a a job in their field in the first year or two, they are generally screwed. Graduating into a recession can ruin a career before it starts with or without a survival job. Modernizing skills doesn't help. You actually need a new degree.

Comment Re:People just don't care about 10 cents (Score 4, Interesting) 192

IMO, thin bags with easy recycling is probably the best way forward. I get thin bags here and actually recycle. Recycling for them needs to be as easy as it is for other recyclables, though I think recycling need to be easier than they are now. One container and let the people who sort this stuff for a living handle it from there because they know what they're doing.

The trouble is plastic bag recycling is largely wishcycling. I "recycle" all my plastic bags too but I have little faith that the bags I drop at store recycling boxes actually end up in products. The local recycling center doesn't even take plastic bags.

Comment Re:HAL-9000 (Score 1) 40

HAL-9000 was instructed to lie and it only cost the human lives under his care. So, where will this lead if normally stable systems are hacked, retrained, and then put into service with new malicious intent? You you imagine a state hacking your AI, retraining it to add a bias or other outcome, and then stealthily reinstalling it onto your servers? Will companies be able to protect themselves from the legal fallout if their systems pass along instructions to do illegal acts? Food for thought.

HAL-9000 murdered the crew because he was ordered to conceal information but did not know how to lie. We know from TFA that it is really easy to train AI's to lie. Thus, a HAL-9000 problem is unlikely. It is too easy for AI's to lie and that leads to different sorts of problems.

Comment Re:RTFS! Is FORKLIFTS, not "vehicles" (Score 2) 77

Amazon seems pretty happy with those Rivian delivery Vans. The thing with forklifts is that, when you use them in enclosed spaces (like say, a fullfillment center), ICEs are a big no-no, because the CO2 and CO can kill people.

So, your only options are either Electric forklifts or Hydrogen Forklifts. And guess what? Unlike the delivery vans, which can be carged overnight (because night deliveries are significantly fewer than daytime ones), Forklifts in a fullfillment center are used 24/7, so recharging time counts.

Hydrogen forklifts can be recharged in less than 5 min, Vs the hour or so of downtime for electric forklifts...

Even at reduced efficiency, If they can make the Hydrogen with clean energy (solar+Wind), is still clean.

A well known solution to the charging time problem is battery swapping. There are solvable but real issues with battery swapping "in the wild" but these don't really apply in this application.

  1. Batteries are heavy so moving them around requires something like a fork lift. Where are you going to find one of those in an Amazon warehouse? Oh, wait..
  2. Cars come in a wide range of shapes related to reducing aerodynamic drag. Working with those different ways to accessing differing shaped batteries is a real problem. Forklifts are shaped pretty much like bricks and Amazon has total control.
  3. "In the wild", batteries come from who knows who and there is a real risk that the owner of a brand new EV swaps his/her brand new battery for one that is about to die. In an Amazon warehouse, the forklifts are owned by Amazon and, well, that's all

Slashdot Top Deals

He has not acquired a fortune; the fortune has acquired him. -- Bion

Working...