Comment Re:Big Brother (Score 2) 515
Threatening someone with jail time or fines if they don't volunteer is like saying there is a mandatory donation required to attend a free event.
So should they also scrap community service and probation options and stick everyone with pure jail-time instead? If you've done something you can be jailed for but they think you'll reform with some minimal oversight I don't see the issue with offering it as an option.
He didn't say that. He's just pointing out, correctly, that "volunteering" means there is little to no incentive to do something, but you do it anyways. Convicted criminals don't "volunteer" to accept community service or probation, they choose it as an alternative to options they consider worse. Just like I don't "volunteer" to go to work every day.
These kids are the same. To call it voluntary is a joke.