NY Times Review of PS3

An anonymous reader noted that the NY Times has done a fairly negative review of the PS3. It would seem that there have been a fair number of these; it's pretty evident at this point that Sony's launch of the PS3 was not exactly well planned out; issues are still rolling in but the real test will be how it does over the holidays and into the next year.

Re:Wii!

[gEvil (beta)]

My thoughts exactly. The only reason I could think of that it hasn't been mentioned is because all the Slashdot editors are busy playing with their Wiis...

Re:Wii!

[Monkeys!!!]

Slashdot is mentioning it.

Every second comment, no matter what the fucking article, is about the Wii.

"After we have dimmed the sun to set back global warming, we can play Mario on our Wii!"

Saying that, I've got a Wii on pre-order :)

Power will not a system make

[Fozzyuw]

Measured in megaflops, gigabytes and other technical benchmarks, the PlayStation 3 is certainly the world's most powerful game console. It falls far short, however, of providing the world's most engaging overall entertainment experience.

yes, and here I was this weekend, playing The Legend of Zelda on my Wii after downloading it for $5 (which I do find expensive, but worth while for this title). Heck, the Zelda game even emulated the frame rate drop when too many orcs are on screen and shooting there bows! Classic! hehe.

I was even more pleasantly surprised when I found my fiancee (who does not like to game) actually use to LOVE Zelda.. and played it for several hours straight... make me a little jealous. hehe

With that said... PS3 is going to have a hard time getting steam. It will probably go the way of the GameCube. A "good" system with a lack of support by 3rd parties. That's not to say the Wii doesn't have it's 'ugly' side too, but from what I've seen from 24 hours of gaming on this thing, it's going to have some outstanding games. Dragon Ball Z is just 10x more fun with the new controller setup! (and this is the next repetitive title in a long franchise, yet it feels fresh!)

Cheers,
Fozzy

Review review review

[UbuntuDupe]

(grr, browser deleted first attempt at response)

There's a lot of "I like the Xbox360 better" in this review. Ok, great. Good luck with that. But this is supposed to be a PS3 review, not a console buying guide that compares the different features. Buy a 360 if you want one. I hear they're great. But "the PS3 is not an XBOX360" is not a valid criticism.

It's not saying "PS3 != Xbox360". It's saying "PS3 lacks what Xbox360 had at the same point in time". And a review should tell me whether it's a waste of money, and the question of whether something comparable is better speaks directly to that.

His first specific criticism is that there's no cable to hook up a PS3 to an HD TV. This is simply incorrect. Sony includes a cable that works fine. It doesn't do HD, but it does hook up and let you use the system. This kind of untruth is to be expected from the NY Times, which is more about an agenda than about accurately describing the factual situation.

Well, that was more to emphasize a deficiency, but I'll agree it was misleading.

There are some things the reviewer found annoying. These are valid points. But it's the first weekend of the PS3. Did everything go perfectly on the first weekend for the XBOX360? Does everything ever go perfectly? This part of the review was not balanced, but it was useful and therefore adequate.

But it was balanced -- at the time of the Xbox360's launch, it was quick to set up. At the PS3's launch, it wasn't. Apples to apples.

There's a paragraph about televisions and walkmans. Does that tell you if the PS3 is fun?

Please, that's just background info, to acknowledge that this is a deviation from a brand's otherwise good historic reputation.

I give your review review a 3.5.

"Who reviews the reviewer reviewers? Reviewer reviewer reviewers review reviewer reviewers."

Re:Power will not a system make

[mgblst]

You realize that the power button was the only form of exercise most gamers were getting, especially now with the ability to download games. This button alone will now add 10% on the average weight of all Americans.

Re:Power will not a system make

[Jeff85]

I for one, am not looking forward to the ability to turn off the console by the controller. I can already imagine sore losers turning off the system right when you're about to beat them in some head-to-head game or just hitting it by accident. And don't bring that "The button is in a place where you can't press it by accident." People claim to push the start button "by accident" all the time when you're trying to do something timed (like say, perform a super strike in Mario Strikers which has those golf-like meters you have to align in the right spot, which is also similar to how most free throws / football field goals are performed in sports games).

Now I'll admit I've never seen the power button mechanism on the wii-motes, and I have no clue where it's located and how it works. But if it's there, I hope they at least made it so that you have to hold it down for like 4 seconds before it turns the Wii off.

Re:Fanboy-talk

[UbuntuDupe]

And a CD is a glorified cassette which is a glorified 8-track which is a glorified record which is a glorified phonograph plate (???) which is a glorified imitation singer which is a glorified minstrel which is a glorified poet which is a glorified storyteller which is a glorified cave wall painting which is a glorified grunt, which was really just to pick up cave chicks anyway before resorting to beating them and dragging them hairwise to your cave.

Re:bitch bItch b1tch

[TommydCat]

Hell, I'll help by throwing in a few paragraph breaks for them to cut and paste...

<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>
<p>

Let me know if you run out and I'll put up a few more to use. :)

Re:Some new things are more than souped-up old thi

[aliquis]

Lol, digital format? Yeah, I remember those analogue cartridges :)

My mario character have become stuck inside the cartridge, how do I fix this? Can I clean it somehow?

Re:The full text

[Anonymous Coward]

tell that to the login page i'm getting