Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

High-Def Disc Interactivity Debuts on HD DVD 135

An anonymous reader writes "Next to picture quality, interactivity has been touted as one of the key selling points of the next-gen disc formats — unlike standard def DVD, both HD DVD and Blu-ray are capable of delivering truly interactive experiences. This past Tuesday, Universal Studios released 'Fast and the Furious: Toyko Drift' on HD DVD with an interactive feature they've dubbed 'U-Control,' delivering the first true on-the-fly, user-controlled supplements to a pre-recorded video format."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

High-Def Disc Interactivity Debuts on HD DVD

Comments Filter:
  • Next to picture quality, interactivity has been touted as one of the key selling points of the next-gen disc formats -- unlike standard def DVD, both HD DVD and Blu-ray are both capable of delivering truly interactive experiences.

    By "interactivity", I'm assuming they mean throwing the player out of a third-story window when it refuses to play a DRM'ed movie that you've paid for [betanews.com]?
    • by NevDull ( 170554 )
      Hell, dude, it's even worse. Interactivity means being able to turn features on which do prerecorded things, on demand. Wow.

      On-demand multiple streams of recorded content took only 35 years after videos first made it to optical discs?
      • by ColaMan ( 37550 )
        Reminds me of those VCD arcade games of the 80's - wouldn't that be defined as "interactive video"?
        You know, those old 'western' type ones. Damned if I can remember the name of it now.

    • I think their new "Interactive" incentive is bundling a Meguires car toweltte in with "The fast and the furious, tokyo drift". No joke, I actually seen this. And the funny part about it was that is cost more than the Movie without the towel. Whoever buys that has issues. 16$ = Movie. 22$ = Movie/ FREE CAR CLEANING TOWEL!!!
    • by inKubus ( 199753 )
      Or maybe throwing yourself out the window if you buy a stupid piece of crap movie like Tokyo "Drift"
  • wth (Score:4, Insightful)

    by RinkyDinks_RJ ( 995306 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:23PM (#16253681)
    And I care about movie interactivity why? It's a friggin movie for crying out loud.
    • Re:wth (Score:5, Insightful)

      by Neil Hodges ( 960909 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:35PM (#16253815)
      I would think that people who want interactivity would play the video game based on the movie. Why would they want to have influence over the movie that they only want to watch, rather than have full control of a simulation in a video game?
    • Re: (Score:1, Insightful)

      by Anonymous Coward
      Again the dumbass mods fail it. Valid question for a stupid technology.

      Regular DVDs have enough storage, enough resolution, enough interactivity (minimal), and are freaking everywhere. No one with half a brain will want to buy their entire movie collection all over again on a format that offers so goddamn little.

      Give it up, corporate fat bastards. We don't want your shitty newer harder to crack technology. FOAD/DIAF.

      Yes, I'm angry. Thanks to greedy fucks that take advantage of people by dangling margin
    • by ergo98 ( 9391 )

      And I care about movie interactivity why? It's a friggin movie for crying out loud.

      Despite the score on your post (currently -1), it's a very valid point -- most extras on DVDs are never viewed (at most I've gone into the deleted scenes for some laughs). Making those interactive will hardly improve them (in fact the interactivity is usually the pain, as you wait for stupid transition scenes to play out between selections), and I marvel that studios still spend the money to produce them.

      Where I think interac

    • "And I care about movie interactivity why? It's a friggin movie for crying out loud."

      Depends on what features are added. I've had DVDs that had some interesting commentaries, for example. The Muppets in Space movie had a neat little gag where it had MST3K'ish chars in the front making comments. The Star Trek DVDs had little blippy 'facts' about the art direction in the shows byh Michael Okuda. (Although why that was some flashy thing with graphics instead of simple text is beyond me...)

      Interactive does
    • by SeaFox ( 739806 )
      And I care about movie interactivity why? It's a friggin movie for crying out loud.

      It's funny how many people say something like this, then complain when a movie comes out on DVD and it's only one disc and doesn't come with anything more than the theatrical trailers for extras. Even more amusing is that the better the movie itself is the more they expect in the way of extras (LOTR, Blade Runner, ect).
  • I'm assuming this content is better than the movie itself. I had to turn the movie off halfway through because the quality level was almost as bad as the second TFATF.
  • Why is this cool? (Score:5, Insightful)

    by crazyjeremy ( 857410 ) * on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:38PM (#16253859) Homepage Journal
    How do these features differ from the simplest video games? So there's some more space available on an HD DVD or Blueray... they just cram the space full with this?

    Unless I don't understand something... what does this add to the movie itself? If it doesn't, then it's just an added feature that has no inherent quality and doesn't aid in my decision to purchase a movie in the first place.
  • Yes, that's whats going to sell it!
  • Movie vs. Features (Score:5, Insightful)

    by corychristison ( 951993 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:42PM (#16253907)
    <rant>
    I don't know about anyone else, but when I watcha movie, I like to watch the movie. Not Flashy, buzz-wordy bull crap.

    Whenever I purchase a new DVD, before I even watch it, I rip it, strip everything but the main movie, and burn it.

    Whoever invented the retarted "feature" to stop you from going directly to the meny during previews is a fucktard. I've only seen it once or twice, but still a complete pain in the ass.

    Then we have the people who enjoy placing a tonne of DRM/copy proctection on the discs and just like to piss people like me off who actually buy movies, and want to just have the main movie start playing when the disc in inserted. Not sit through a bunch of warnings, movie previews, and then sit at the goddamn menu until you have to press the play button. I can see sometimes this can be of use, but in more cases than not, I just want to watch TFM[ovie]!

    In conclusion, I want better content, not features. Stop waisting your time and money on crap nobody cares about.
    </rant>
    Sorry. I just had to get that off my chest.
    • by geekoid ( 135745 )
      Some features are a huge draw to DVDs.

      But yeah, when I put it in, just start.

      Some childrens movies will start automatically if they sit at the main menu for a little while. Still ahve to go through the FBI warning, then the MPAA psuedo warning.

      • Still ahve to go through the FBI warning, then the MPAA psuedo warning.

        I don't like the fact that you can't click past the copyright warnings but I think it is much worse that the same feature is used to force you to watch the studio splash.

    • by Rakarra ( 112805 )
      I actually want the menus, but I don't want a menu sequence. That is, when the menu comes up, I want to be able, at that very moment, to click on the options (usually sound and subtitle information). Forget the previews, forget the copyright notice. Just a responsive menu without some "oooh, sit back and look at what we whipped up" menu sequence.
    • The DVD "feature" that prevents you from skipping the FBI warning and the trailers at the beginning of your DVD is called User Operationg Prohibition [wikipedia.org] When you rip your dvd's and reburn them, the software removes the flag so your palyer will let you skip those sections.

      But back when I was looking for an all-region dvd player, i found that some players have hacks to remove recognition of UOP flags. I'm glad I did - I find UOP Flag more annoying than the region locking, since I have to deal with UOP with

    • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

      by Firehed ( 942385 )
      You must be my long-lost brother (or switched with the current one that I'm trying to lose). Almost my entire movie collection - at least, that which isn't ripped to Xvid on my hard drive - is a burned copy of the original with the movie and, that's it. Put it in, it plays. No "you can't skip this", no waiting for six minutes of pre-menu animation, no dozen FBI warnings in three languages, and no previews (the one REAL improvement the first DVDs had over VHS).

      Of course, not all players seem to like my DV
    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      by MrSteveSD ( 801820 )
      I only recently discovered how annoyed my parents were with DVDs, compared to their old Video Recorder. They are very frustrated that they can't whizz through all the crap at the beginning.

      I've noticed that on some DVD's you can just skip to the root menu, but others make you watch every single company logo and FBI warning. Do we really care that the DVD can't be watched on Oil Rigs? Given the minuscule number of people living on Oil Rigs, is it at all fair to take up our time with that crap?
    • I don't know about anyone else, but when I watcha movie, I like to watch the movie. Not Flashy, buzz-wordy bull crap.

      And when you see a /. story, you want to jump right to the ranting and complaining, not take time to think about the subject for a few minutes...

      I'm sure people had the same complaint about video games when they were introduced. Not to mention FMVs...

      There are different kinds of movies being churned out by Hollywood these days. One type you want to sit back and watch... The other, they cou

  • Most of the interactive features of DVD's were never used seriously,
    to create a new viewing experience.

    How many DVD's really had useful multiple angles?
    - Like perhaps a Fixed camera, vs one that panned.
    How many DVD's had a useful alternate audio track.
    - Like a music only (matrix came close), or without drama music.
    How many DVD's had seamless alternate endings or alternate paths.
    (not just an all too common alternate ending presented like a deleted scence.)

    The features of DVD should be used be
    • by Rakarra ( 112805 )
      - Like a music only (matrix came close), or without drama music.

      Amadeus comes with an excellent music-only track. Mozart wrote some fantastic stuff, and it's nice to just pop in the dvd and listen. Or even watch the movie only with the music to see how each piece was chosen to convey mood and suppliment emotion.

    • by Ucklak ( 755284 )
      Like Legend with the Jerry Goldsmith track or the Tangerine Dream track. Instead you get 2 DVDs.
    • by 1u3hr ( 530656 )
      How many DVD's had a useful alternate audio track. - Like a music only (matrix came close), or without drama music

      Or sitcoms where you can turn off the laugh track. Though in a lot of shows you'd then notice an an awkward-looking pause.

  • by Anonymous Coward on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:53PM (#16254011)
    Once again, the porn industry drives technology forward. It will be very "interesting" to see what they come up with for this feature!
  • Why not just shove a bunch of shots onto the disk and let the user play them in whatever order they like. Save money because you can fire the editors. And you can label it 'truly interactive' to sell it for more money. Guaranteed profit.
  • by noidentity ( 188756 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @07:56PM (#16254043)
    I can guarantee you DVDs and successors will never give interactivity where it's most wanted: being able to put the disc in the player and press ONE button ONCE and have it immediately start playing the ACTUAL MOVIE. No way. To get that feature, you have to break the law and copy the DVD.
    • We can't have that. We need several minutes of ads. And it sure can't play the movie after that! Customer experience? Who cares!

      It SHOULD just play the damn movie the moment you stick the disc in. It doesn't.
    • by SeaFox ( 739806 )
      I can guarantee you DVDs and successors will never give interactivity where it's most wanted: being able to put the disc in the player and press ONE button ONCE and have it immediately start playing the ACTUAL MOVIE.


      Both DVD players in my house do that. Open tray, put in disc, hit PLAY button on front of player, disc starts playing the movie just like I had brought up the main menu screen and chosen "Play Move" from there.
  • I don't know about others of the Slashdot crowd but most of the time I see absolutely no need for movie extras really. I want to watch a movie, sometimes its fun to see extra scenes but really some of them were cut for a reason. I mean how much of the price of a dvd or one of these HD dvds is going to be paying someone to program these interactive features.
    • by geekoid ( 135745 )
      Some of them are cut for time.
      One of the best scenes in Galaxy Quest was cut for time, and I'd like to see it in context.

      Same thing with unbreakable. There are two VERY powerfull scenes that were cut at the last minute which I'd like to see in context as well.

      Yeah, most of them wouldn't look to good since they probably didn't get to the final stages of editing.
      • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

        by MikeBabcock ( 65886 )
        This is the case in the Bourne Identity which allows you to play the original theatrical version or the new beginning and ending tacked on as well. Several movies I've seen do this already (and the additional footage is of course lower quality).

        The one I'd love to see though is say the Lord of the Rings trilogy done so you can watch the theatrical version (for the shorter-movie-loving wife) or the DVD versions turning on or off the extra scenes live (and switching to the appropriate version of the soundtra
    • sometimes its fun to see extra scenes but really some of them were cut for a reason
      I see you have made an input error. Let me correct it for you:
      sometimes its fun to see extra scenes but really most of them were cut for a reason

      Enjoy. :-)
      • Actually, they are often cut for stupid reasons. For example, ask a Hollywood director how easy it is to get a studio to accept a comedy movie that lasts longer than 90 minutes.
  • Isn't this what was promised with DVDs?
    Why yes, yes it was.

    I have yet to see a DVD player that contains all the features of Laser Disk.
    • by garcia ( 6573 )
      I have yet to see a DVD player that contains all the features of Laser Disk.

      And I haven't seen a Laser Disc player since I was in 7th grade and it's not like it's because they're had to see because of their size ;)
  • Pr0n (Score:2, Insightful)

    by not-admin ( 943926 )
    I have a feeling this might actually end up being a main selling point for the disk format...

    After all, doesn't everyone want more intereactivity in their pornography?
  • by Dachannien ( 617929 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @08:15PM (#16254227)
    Announcer: If you want Calculon to race to the laser gun battle in his hover-Ferarri, press 1! If you want Calculon to double-check his paperwork, press 2! Enter now!
    Fry presses 1.
    Chair: You have pressed 2!
    Fry: No, I didn't!
    Chair: I'm almost positive you did!
    Time passes.
    Calculon: Add in the carryover from form 16A, then deduct line 2B...
  • If the studios keep pumping out crap like Fast and the Furious, they'll continue to see box office decline, slumping interest, skyrocketing piracy, and marginal adoption of new technology. Generally bad things for the forseeable future.
    • i get your point, but i really can't see how poor quality increases piracy, however much we'd like to be punishing movie studios for crap content. how does it work? this movie sucks, so i'll use up 4GB (or 1.2GB, or whatever) of my drive, and use my bandwidth to share it? i think poor quality probably deters piracy.
      • by in2mind ( 988476 )
        but i really can't see how poor quality increases piracy, however much we'd like to be punishing movie studios for crap content. how does it work?

        Its quite simple.The case with low quality movies is this - The consumer wants to watch the movie.However,he deems it not good enough for the hassle of driving to theatre,pay for family etc.Instead he thinks the movie is just worth a watch on computer & delete.

    • Actually Fast and the Furious # 3 has 20% more plot than the previous two movies combined.
      If it wasn't for that guy's (Lucas Black aka "Sean Boswell" in the movie) absolutely horrible accent, the movie would be pretty hard to top.

      Plus it'll lead way for Need For Speed: Carbon- bringing back the drift modes again.

      In any case, it wasn't that bad.

      -M
  • They have tried this over and over again about 10-odd years ago with "Interactive Movies", basically 'games' that you could pick cutscenes in, little more than that. They failed miserably and terribly, except for the odd corner case.

    Apparently, history does repeat itself (and they still haven't learned from the previous mistake).

    When people put a movie in, they want to be *passively entertained*. Having the brain in between two states (passive and active) doesn't really work.
    • by Ucklak ( 755284 )
      Bob Gale of Back to the Future fame experiemented with interactive movies after BTTF ran its course.

      The only interactive people want in media is video games, and not everyone is a gamer. Most people want to be entertained.
    • If you RTFA, you'd see that these "interactive" additions are little different from VH-1's "Pop-up Video". The things metioned are picture-in-picture interviews during the movie, concept art overlays, "GPS" (a sort of bird's eye view of the race scenes, kinda like the track map in a game), and pop-up stats about the cars.

      You don't get to decide the outcome of the movie. The "good guy" still wins. And Nathalie Kelley is still hot.
  • Pr0n (Score:3, Funny)

    by king-manic ( 409855 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @08:36PM (#16254423)
    It'll be huge for porn. They already do choose your own camera angle. They can now do it with higher definition. See that $5 whore and her meth teeth in 1080p with 5.1 surround to truly capture what it's like to be seedy and cheap all from the comforts of home. See every pimple, needle mark, ruise, and wrinkle.
    • Uh, isn't the point supposed to be that you can change the camera angle so that you can't see her teeth, pimple, needle mark, ruise and wrinkle esp since it will be in HD? ;) Suggestion: Maybe you should spend more than $5 on your porn so they can pay for a better "actress"!
    • Hey man easy with the stereotyping. There are plenty of brainy broads out there in pr0n. Like Thomas Pynchon's niece: http://www.nypost.com/seven/09282006/gossip/pagesi x/pagesix.htm [nypost.com] (New York Post). Just because they're taking it in the dumper on film to make a living does not mean that they're all meth head junkies. Some are oversexed coeds from ultra liberal arts colleges who view the money as just an added bonus for what they would be doing in their spare time anyway. When I used to write for the C
  • There were some pretty interesting things that could be done with the programming language that DVDs use, but to my knowledge it wasn't to the point of being able to write meaningful games. I wonder if the "interactivity" means including things like a pseudorandom number generator so one could throw in, for example, a video poker game as an easter egg (or is there a way to do this on regular DVDs that didn't occur to me?)
  • Here we go again! (Score:2, Insightful)

    by WWWWolf ( 2428 )

    delivering the first true on-the-fly, user-controlled supplements to a pre-recorded video format.

    Great! The people who missed 1995 in videogames have finally a chance to relive the legendary golden era of Full Motion Video Multimedia CD-ROM Games! A little bit less compression artifacts, but the same two-penny production values, the same horrible acting, the same cheesy special effects and especially the same level of interactivity!

    ::runs in fear as the memories of the Philips CD-i commercials flood i

  • It should be easy (as far as movies and games go in general) to write, say, an XBOX 360 game that is just streaming VC1/MPEG4/H.264 video most of the time and occasionally drops into mini-action sequences so that you have to kill an enemy, win a car race or otherwise influence movie's branching storyline. Interactive features on players without a decent CPU/GPU are doomed to be amatuerish in comparison, so why even bother?
  • I would assume that I'm not too far off from others when I say that I don't particularly enjoy these features inserted into the movies. Also, how is the end result of this different from what DVD could do? The technology is better, and more interesting, but for which applications could they be used that truly make the users' experience better?

    The PIP is neat, but I for one have never sat all the way through a movie a second time to hear the commentary. This just adds a small box with video content to that
    • by ColaMan ( 37550 )
      The only time I've ever sat through an audio commentary was with 'Goldeneye' and the only reason was that the producers and directors that were doing the commentary, sounded like they had had about 6 beers beforehands, and were genuinely having a good time about it. Poked fun at some girl who won a 'bond girl' contest about 10 years before that movie that gave her a bit part, and was now looking a bit worse for wear now, etc.

      But saying all that, I'd accidentally hit the button for the audio commentary track
  • BluRay (Score:4, Interesting)

    by SQLz ( 564901 ) on Friday September 29, 2006 @09:16PM (#16254723) Homepage Journal
    Ok, in the past I've bashed BlueRay,and HD DVD. Today I went to the Sony Global Marketing Conference on Sony Pictures lot. BlueRay is damn impressive. I was more impressed with BluRay and the new Bravia line of TVs than I was with the PS3. The picture quality is unbelievable compared to DVD, and on 52 inch 1080p bravias, it was awesome. PS3 wise, they had the offical hardware. There was 4 playable PS3 machines. You could just walk up and play. They were also using PS3s to play BluRay movies on a few TVs, incluing an 82 inch LCD that was playing PS3 trailers. There was a dirt bike game which had some sweet physics, GT HD, an anime looking golf game with litte girls in short skirts, and a WWII era FPS where the nazi's look like zombies. The graphics we decent (not PC quality for sure), the sound quality was amazing.
    • ok.. a few things i caught in that rant:

      -52in 1080p bravia
      -82in LCD

      can you say... rich people's toys.. and no i don't mean middle class and up i mean RICH people's toys!

      my family is arguably upper middle class and cannot afford that crap, as is about 80% of the american population, and at a projected 1800 bucks a BD player youre looking at the requirement for even more obscene amounts of cash..

      I don't think joe sixpack is willing to sell half his organs, his arms, his legs, and farm out his brain to a super
    • For those of you who care:

      Dirt bike game (also allows cars and other vehicles): Motorstorm

      Golf game: minna no golf (Everyone's Golf)

      WWII era FPS: Resistance: Fall of Man
  • Anyone else get offended by being marketed to this way on Slashdot?
  • They might address their sagging sales to the fact that instead of releasing good movies, they release titles like "fast and the furious, tokyo drift".

    let's see.. direct the platform toward the 27-55 demographic.. market movies for the platform to the 12-22 demographic.. I think i'm seeing their problem here!
  • "Next to picture quality, interactivity has been touted as one of the key selling points of the next-gen disc formats ... This past Tuesday, Universal Studios released 'Fast and the Furious: Toyko Drift' on HD DVD..."

    Maybe, instead of adding fancy user controlled content, they should use that money hire more competent writers, directors and actors, so that we are being sold media based on the quality of the IP contained inside, not how many different angles you can look at Vin Diesel's Orc crushing arms [ugo.com].
  • I have had Dragons Lair http://www.amazon.com/Dragons-Lair-Don-Bluth/dp/B 0 0000INHR [amazon.com] and a few other of the "laserdisc games" on DVD for years now. You can play if on your PC or on your DVD player using your remote control (mine uses the up/down/left/right arrows). Wouldn't this be considered interactive? I mean, if I don't push any buttons, it just sits there.
    Plus, the latest Final Destination DVD http://www.amazon.com/Final-Destination-Widescreen -Two-Disc-Special/dp/B000FC2HS6/ref=imdbpov_dvd_2/ 102-6203 [amazon.com]
  • Of course there are all the obligitory comments above about how commentaries are stupid, and special features are stupid, and interactivity is stupid, but must have missed the thread where people actually discussed how these new features are technically achieved, and I for one would like to know.

    I know I've seen some really neat things done in the past that took advantage of the unused capabilities of DVDs, or that used them in new and interesting ways.

    • Men in Black - my favourite commentary, they had
    • From what I've observed:

      • Men in Black: Almost certainly a separate title. I don't believe DVDs currently do any compositing at all, except possibly the menus. I suppose it's possible they could've made the whole movie a "menu", but even if they did, it would've been incredibly clumsy.
      • X-Men 1: I wish I'd seen this kind of feature more often. In fact, I've never seen it at all, except by offering the director's cut as a separate DVD.
      • Final Destination 3: This is the extent of how I believe DVDs wor
  • Seriously this is a decent idea, I know many Slashdotters would call this censorship or something but bare with me.

    Release multi-rating DVD's. Mom and the kids can watch the movie at PG-13 if they want... Pastor Bob can get it PG rated and grandpa can opt for the R or unrated version. Hey parents can set the kids TV to block R rated stuff (V-Chip) and then get little Timmy a copy of Pitch Black (To go along with his standard PG-13 Chronicles of Riddick) which he can watch at PG-13 until he's older.

    Why not
    • Tricky, because you'd have to implement it as a standard, and it's probably too late for either Blu-ray or HD-DVD. Also tricky, because it now means that you now can't refuse to sell, say, X-rated material, because most DVDs will include unrated or X-rated material for those who want it. And there's probably a whole other can of worms I haven't even touched on.

      But I like it. I like it becaues it means I'll just allow all content, but they'll be less afraid of putting "strong" content in films that really
    • Release multi-rating DVD's. Mom and the kids can watch the movie at PG-13 if they want... Pastor Bob can get it PG rated and grandpa can opt for the R or unrated version. Hey parents can set the kids TV to block R rated stuff (V-Chip) and then get little Timmy a copy of Pitch Black (To go along with his standard PG-13 Chronicles of Riddick) which he can watch at PG-13 until he's older.

      What's funny is we don't even need a new player to do something like that. Just add extra DVD scene cuts at the points where

  • Now they have an excuse to resell Dragon's Lair and Space Ace again! Oh boy.
  • This isn't anything new, we've been able to do overlays on DVDs already, whether it's MST3K-like shadows providing commentary, or something like a body count (just use a subtitle track) like what was mentioned in the article. We've also been able to have storyboards accompanying the main movie. Whether it's PIP embedded in the video and you have to flip over the disc (due to storage limitation on DVD), or a simultaneous stream of audio or a seperate sub-picture, we're able to do it on DVD already. This d
  • Comment removed based on user account deletion

"Look! There! Evil!.. pure and simple, total evil from the Eighth Dimension!" -- Buckaroo Banzai

Working...