Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
The Media

salimma's Journal: Russian election prediction 4

Journal by salimma

One feels an unshakable sense of déjà vu upon hearing about the recent train bombing near Rostov-on-Don in southern Russia. The more cynical, or paranoid, amongst us might be tempted to point the finger at shadowy security services - we are talking about Russia, after all, with oblique behind-the-scenes machinations. And one certainly cannot doubt that Putin did well out of the 1999 apartment bombings, just as GW Bush gained political capital out of 9/11. I would like to stress that I condemn all these attacks, and in no way sympathize with anti-American, anti-Israeli conspiracy theories that either CIA or Mossad planned the 9/11 attacks.

Regardless of the identity of the perpetrator, it seems likely that the Kremlin's announted party, United Russia, would gain political mileage out of security fears and patriotism. Less certain is the relative position of the opposition parties in the new Duma. Many analysts seem to be of the opinion that the liberals - in Russia encompassing both the neo-liberal economists at Union of Right Forces as well as Grigory Yavlinsky's social-democratic Yabloko - would be decimated and the Communist party reduced in strength. The Kremlin, and Putin, would thus be stronger than ever.

I would respectfully beg to differ. First of all, Union of Right Forces was pro-Putin after the '99 election, while today there is talk of its merger with Yabloko (another déjà vu here, reminding one of the absorption of the Liberal Party into the Democratic Party of Japan, though in this case it would be intriguing to see who absorbs who - URF is larger but more discredited, Yabloko has integrity but not much support). And demographics would continue to plague the Communists - they are in a similar position to the Conservatives in the UK, limited to an ever-graying support base. The closure of independent media outlets, on the other hand, might hurt the liberals more, simply on the strength of name recognition.

What, then, might happen today? I predict an increase in support for United Russia, though short of obtaining a two-thirds majority; a rout for the Communists, a slightly less steep decline for URF and a slight decline for Yabloko - its supporters have nowhere else to go, really, and the recent arrest of Khodorkovsky might play into the liberals' hands as much as it helps United Russia - those hankering for a strong state would desert the Communists for Putin, those wishing for a liberal democracy's respect for due process voting for Yabloko. The Kremlin would thus command roughly the same amount of parliamentarians, but this time they would be even more beholden to the President than ever before.

Update - my prediction seems to be almost spot on, at least when it comes to popular vote. Alas, one neglected to take in the impact of the 5% threshold - thanks to Yabloko and SPS' failure to come together for the election, they were both almost wiped out.

In any case, one wonders how much their planned election pact would have helped - it certainly would help in the first-past-the-post constituencies, but whether an election pact carrying 8% would result in its members receiving proportional seats is a rather technical matter.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Russian election prediction

Comments Filter:
  • by bj8rn (583532)
    Sadly, from what I've read, United Russia will probably obtain a large majority, maybe even two thirds of the seats in Duma. Some of the few remaining independent analysts in Russia have pointed out, that:

    1) The public have been given a signal, they know who they have to vote for (just like in the old days...). The best example of this is a poll about TV debates: the most people voted for United Russia to have performed the best in the debates on TV -- but not a single member of United Russia took part in
    • 1) The public have been given a signal, they know who they have to vote for (just like in the old days...). ...

      2) Fabrication of votes will probably occur. The Kremlin has a lot of experience in this.

      Unfortunately true - brings to mind the recent 'elections' in Chechnya and Georgia. I should probably have qualified my predictions, stating they should hold provided no massive irregularities take place. Given the precedent, not very hopeful, I know.

      On the other hand, Hun Sen was in a similar situation to Pu

      • I don't think there has ever been a democracy in Russia. And I'm not optimistic about the future, either...

        As for the train explosion, Kavkaz Center [kavkaz.org.uk] has quite an interesting take on the situation.

        • Being an Indonesian, the situation is rather ironic. The country used to be democratic (1949-1959), slided into authoritarianism, coups and counter-coups, until the re-emergence of political freedom in 1998 with the toppling of then-dictator Suharto.

          After that? We plunged straight back into money politics, most politicians are left-overs from the previous era, and.. the current president has authoritarian tendencies to the point of being hostile towards the press and shrouding herself in mystery. The leade

The economy depends about as much on economists as the weather does on weather forecasters. -- Jean-Paul Kauffmann

Working...